Someone Dead Ruined My Life… Again.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024
  • Videos like this are only possible with your help, consider becoming a bonnie bee today! / cgpgrey
    Related Videos
    💖 The Tale of Tiffany 💖 • 💖 The History of The T...
    Physical Characteristics of The Tiffanys: • Physical Characteristi...
    Brief History of the Royal Family: • Brief History of the R...
    Discussion on Cortex Episode out of Time -- Rio Heist: • #120: Episode Out of T...
    The first time: • The Race to Win Staten...
    Bonnie Bees
    Ben Delo, Bob Kunz, Bobby, Nevin Spoljaric, Donal Botkin, BN-12, Andrew Bereza, Rebecca Wortham, Richard Jenkins, Marco Arment, Phil Gardner, Martin, Steven Grimm, Colin Millions, emptymachine, George Lin, Jason Lewandowski, Saki Comandao, David Tyler, iulus, Jordan Earls, Nick Fish, Nick Gibson, Tyler Bryant, Xueqi, Oliver Steele, Kermit Norlund, rictic, Alex Simonides, Tim Stumbaugh, Nicholas Welna, Christopher Mutchler, Derek Bonner, Mikko, Orbit_Junkie, Tómas Árni Jónasson, Bear, chrysilis, David Palomares, Drago175, Emil, Esteban Santana Santana, Freddi Hørlyck, John Rogers, Peter Lomax, Rhys Parry, ShiroiYami, Tristan Watts-Willis, Veronica Peshterianu, Dag Viggo Lokøen, John Lee, Maxime Zielony, Elizabeth Keathley, Birdstryke, AUFFRAY Clement
    Music
    David Rees: www.davidreesmu...

Комментарии • 18 тыс.

  • @veritasium
    @veritasium 3 года назад +69389

    Grey, any time you need to talk about Tiff just give me a call.

    • @WarlordofWarren
      @WarlordofWarren 3 года назад +885

      Neat

    • @tobias6249
      @tobias6249 3 года назад +566

      Nice to see you here!

    • @Hydan16
      @Hydan16 3 года назад +1270

      The greatest minds gather themselves on places you would never expect

    • @kman6004
      @kman6004 3 года назад +890

      You two should do some kind of colab where you make/prove some kind of physics claim and Grey has to dive endlessly into the historical significance

    • @PeterPhillipsVaycent
      @PeterPhillipsVaycent 3 года назад +329

      Hahaha I legitimately hope Grey gets back to you. This is the collab we need

  • @AnimeFan-wd5pq
    @AnimeFan-wd5pq 3 года назад +2289

    I love the fact that a 35 page letter roasting a person’s documentation book survived the annals of history and managed to be shared to millions of people to become remembered for ages past its prime.

    • @shieldanvilitkovian9541
      @shieldanvilitkovian9541 3 года назад +89

      Past it's prime? No sir, it's been aged well, and can probably stand for another 300 years.

    • @conorstapleton3183
      @conorstapleton3183 3 года назад +24

      If he would have had more time, he would have written a shorter letter.

  • @TokuNorth
    @TokuNorth 3 года назад +1199

    I love how Grey just casually brushes off the earliest known reference to Robin Hood in order to search for Tiffany

    • @Dave-ks9fi
      @Dave-ks9fi 3 года назад +40

      She was well known to his men around the camp.

    • @destruct0503
      @destruct0503 3 года назад +88

      Thats because the Robin hood reference has been well researched multiple times (its not the one in the scotichronicon) and his topic was Tiffany, which hasn't been researched

    • @karolkozik5918
      @karolkozik5918 3 года назад +22

      And insists on reading roman numerals as letters.

    • @TokuNorth
      @TokuNorth 3 года назад +11

      @@karolkozik5918 Well, that IS how you read them

    • @karolkozik5918
      @karolkozik5918 3 года назад +11

      @@TokuNorth Well I know, but... Alright, you win. I just think reading it the "normal" way would at least lead some non-historical people towards trying to learn Roman numerals. Of course they're as useful in modern times as Latin itself, sed sicut Brianum Davidus Gilbertus dixit, "Scientia potentia est". - written on X.IX.MMXXI

  • @scientificconsideration8294
    @scientificconsideration8294 Год назад +6662

    I love how Alexander Pope's message was essentially "Thomas Hearne is a hoarding prick" and Grey, after months of excruciating work, basically confirmed it.

  • @odhgkg
    @odhgkg 3 года назад +9843

    Grey’s willingness to dive absurdly deep into the most seemingly simple topics just shows how incredibly complex and interesting our world really is

  • @Burntheguitarist
    @Burntheguitarist 3 года назад +15489

    The scottish history section being located in a perpetually unlit section of an English library is the most beautifully poetic thing I think I have seen

    • @Ok-lu8gx
      @Ok-lu8gx 3 года назад +77

      ok

    • @jospinner1183
      @jospinner1183 3 года назад +1323

      Presumably the Irish history section is just a pile of self-congratulatory texts by an assortment of Englishmen.

    • @Xentillus
      @Xentillus 3 года назад +510

      @@jospinner1183 It's a baked potato stall

    • @salvadorgiron5527
      @salvadorgiron5527 3 года назад +23

      Truth

    • @thericepotato5847
      @thericepotato5847 3 года назад +209

      @@jospinner1183 It would be, but the books went to war and all but the most important texts got burned in the ensuing scuffle

  • @Lanfairya
    @Lanfairya 3 года назад +5745

    "Provided nothing of value" - actually, I will be sending this to a friend who is a history teacher who will most likely use it as a way to demonstrate to students how misinformation can take root and be passed down through the centuries and why checking the original source material is so incredibly important. It may actually provide far greater value than you realize.

    • @EcceJack
      @EcceJack 3 года назад +322

      Certainly! One could go so far as to say that highlighting these difficulties is even more important than ever before in *gestures broadly* _these_ current times! Showing how doing proper research might take a lot of time, and not lead anywhere

    • @TheDramacist
      @TheDramacist 3 года назад +117

      But the lesson here is not to obsess over the source until you check that the content of the material is of any factual accuracy to begin with

    • @roryschussler
      @roryschussler 3 года назад +336

      Grey is relatively lucky here.
      For a researcher, you'll often be frustrated by sloppy scholarship that allows inaccuracies to be written down as truth.
      It's rare that you'll actually find the direct source of the misinformation *and* get the schadenfreude of watching him get brutally dunked on by one of the greatest satirists in the English language.

    • @StoryTeller796
      @StoryTeller796 2 года назад +40

      Yeah, this is one of the best videos that I have seen that depict misinformation.

    • @link_team3855
      @link_team3855 2 года назад +29

      check the sources of your source's sources

  • @Color_Splsh
    @Color_Splsh 2 года назад +7351

    Grey has just done the real, actual, unironic job of a historian.

  • @lahusahah1994
    @lahusahah1994 3 года назад +1030

    Alexander Pope would probably love how much trouble Hearne's mistakes have frustrated Grey's research. I'd imagine he'd write an open letter to the public criticizing Hearne for causing so much hassle.

    • @AbsolXGuardian
      @AbsolXGuardian 3 года назад +124

      "This scholar and writer of pamphlets for the education of the public was driven to madness."

    • @tolman4497
      @tolman4497 3 года назад +60

      alexander pope sounds like a hilarious guy

    • @bulldozer8950
      @bulldozer8950 3 года назад +63

      “His misinformation and inclusions of useless misquoted works cost true researchers of valuable time”

    • @hrolvnir
      @hrolvnir 3 года назад +59

      he would've written an open letter *praising hearne for "inducing in others so much scholarly effort and doubly admirable for doing with so lightly of his own"

    • @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721
      @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 3 года назад +12

      I think Grey might have been possessed by Pope's spirit for a bit.

  • @bencalvin8258
    @bencalvin8258 3 года назад +877

    There's nothing more CGPGrey than "I thought I had someone I could finally talk to about this, but he died 100 years ago"

    • @ellemourto1527
      @ellemourto1527 3 года назад +19

      Yeeah, that made me laugh out loud xD

  • @speakertomeat
    @speakertomeat 3 года назад +6965

    I love how centuries later Grey finds himself in agreement with Pope's despise of Hearne

    • @huhwerami4417
      @huhwerami4417 3 года назад +364

      Pope despising hearne was not unwarranted

    • @Lumberjack_king
      @Lumberjack_king 2 года назад +56

      @chula chalupa it wasn’t pointless

    • @FroggerbobT
      @FroggerbobT 2 года назад +23

      @chula chalupa Wasn't pointless. It proved that Hearne was a shithead that couldn't do his job right.

    • @ashtar3876
      @ashtar3876 2 года назад +59

      @chula chalupa yeah no hearne definitely deserved that from making grey go insane from this poem

    • @LiveFreeOrDieDH
      @LiveFreeOrDieDH 2 года назад +2

      Alex Pope wins again...

  • @EbonMaster
    @EbonMaster 2 года назад +6931

    I think this is important as it shows how a single person's incompetency can spread misinformation for literally hundreds of years. This is a small thing but how many of these small things are there out there that end up changing the total narrative either through this same level of incompetency or intentionally? The idea is so fascinating to me that it almost makes me wish I took up history.

    • @mrahzzz
      @mrahzzz 2 года назад +272

      Right!!?? Makes me really interested in theory of information and communication. We see it in things like childhood games of "telephone," in common misconceptions, etc, but we give too much credit that things will get shaken out and that sources speak from a place of professional practice or well studied confidence, when in reality misinformation is so easy to spread... Suuuper interesting.

    • @greywolf7577
      @greywolf7577 Год назад +46

      So do we know anything about history? Should I question the truth of anything that happened before I was born?

    • @twincitiestara
      @twincitiestara Год назад

      @@greywolf7577 "Know" is probably too strong a word for it. We are "relatively confident" that Hannibal crossed the Alps and a couple of his elephants survived the journey. Okay, maybe we just suspect it, but we're relatively confident that the Punic Wars happened. Probably.

    • @whyplaypiano2844
      @whyplaypiano2844 Год назад +122

      @@greywolf7577 Yes, isn't that obvious? You have the power to test anything you want within reason. If you have skepticism, then by all means, attempt to debunk whatever it is you're skeptical about.

    • @toddalexander5015
      @toddalexander5015 11 месяцев назад +23

      I want a netflix series about this just so we can see some character acter gnashing his teeth into the scenery playing these historical people

  • @Wobby266
    @Wobby266 3 года назад +3439

    "Is anyone still even watching?" Yes, me. And loving every second of this batshit crazy journey through minor points in history.

    • @green0563
      @green0563 3 года назад +39

      Yup, me too.

    • @godsdj7316
      @godsdj7316 3 года назад +19

      "Is anyone here?" Yup, me too!

    • @tekbox7909
      @tekbox7909 3 года назад +6

      Same

    • @melanieodhner4686
      @melanieodhner4686 3 года назад +6

      Same!

    • @rktt9619
      @rktt9619 3 года назад +8

      “Anyway, snap out of it, carrying on.” broke me :D

  • @MrDrPfrPatrick
    @MrDrPfrPatrick 3 года назад +26269

    WHY THE POEM IS A JOKE:
    It's a pun based on "coming out of Britany".
    William's mother was named Britany.
    The poem is implying that his mother gave birth to the man, his wife, his maid, and his dog.
    It's an ancient "yo mama" joke.

    • @clickthisforawsomnes
      @clickthisforawsomnes 3 года назад +3006

      I’m 99% sure your 100% right

    • @jacobarcher1097
      @jacobarcher1097 3 года назад +2138

      I think your right and I'm not sure if that makes it better or worse

    • @kyokyodisaster4842
      @kyokyodisaster4842 3 года назад +2418

      ...Ah, a yo-mama joke...
      Truely worthy of baseline of Tiffany.

    • @MissPoplarLeaf
      @MissPoplarLeaf 3 года назад +822

      That's hilarious, and I hope it's true

    • @CMF412
      @CMF412 3 года назад +170

      That's awesome.

  • @geoffreydesena587
    @geoffreydesena587 3 года назад +2346

    I completely disagree, Grey. This was not at all a waste of time. This was an incredible adventure for you and for all of us. Getting lost in the world's largest library over the course of a year sounds like one of the most fulfilling adventures one could embark upon. After years of freeloading this wonderful content, I'm happy to be able to contribute financially for once.

    • @guest_informant
      @guest_informant 3 года назад +41

      The moral of the story is "Life is a journey not a destination, " and/or, "Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans."
      Yes, basically this is a fable.

    • @billcipherproductions1789
      @billcipherproductions1789 3 года назад +4

      @@guest_informant Exactly.

    • @TheWinglessHawk
      @TheWinglessHawk 3 года назад +10

      Loved that too and don't forget the sweet sweet roast. >:D Have to look up Alexander Pope. I like his style and sass.

    • @mehranhodiwala1273
      @mehranhodiwala1273 3 года назад

      @@guest_informant ah, a John Lennon fan I see

    • @fii_89639
      @fii_89639 3 года назад +7

      Indeed, the thought that 50 years from now, Grey's video (and it's AI-written auto-transcript no doubt) will be one more stone in the path surrounding the bibliographies of these ancient people quoting each other.

  • @Slash0mega
    @Slash0mega 2 года назад +4416

    cgp grey, exasperated: "I DON'T EVEN KNOW IF ANYONE IS STILL LISTENING AT THIS POINT!"
    me, being entranced by the centuries old drama about Hearne while eating a Klondike bar: "ya, I'm with ya"

  • @jackjennaway1727
    @jackjennaway1727 3 года назад +1647

    This really makes you appreciate just how much knowledge is out there, perhaps published in only a single book, just waiting to be lost forever.

    • @arsenalfanatic09
      @arsenalfanatic09 3 года назад +76

      a thing we take for granted about internet information is that someone put it there out of the goodness of their heart/archival instincts.
      Wikipedia is a large collaborative project. Even mentioning info is a huge deal. I was trying to find the source of an obscure quote I thought i heard from a sports commentator, and I only found one forum post from 2004ish on it, from a now defunct forum about TV.
      Sidenote: i don't like that forums have gone away. it's useful to have conversations between random strangers preserved and web-crawlable, and it's not as easy to do with external tools with twitter or facebook.

    • @fawkestheplotphoenix964
      @fawkestheplotphoenix964 3 года назад +2

      You sir are depressing

    • @Rhannmah
      @Rhannmah 3 года назад +14

      And then you remember about the Library of Alexandria

    • @Pensive_Scarlet
      @Pensive_Scarlet 3 года назад

      @Marci Schneider You must be trolling. .__.

  • @TammyJerkChicken
    @TammyJerkChicken 3 года назад +15206

    I love that this channel is just “proper research is agony”

    • @kennedytheretard975
      @kennedytheretard975 3 года назад +318

      Because it kinda is

    • @timspoor
      @timspoor 3 года назад +53

      Yes!

    • @svchineeljunk-riggedschoon4038
      @svchineeljunk-riggedschoon4038 3 года назад +282

      Here's a research hole for you - look to see if the late neolithic tribes in western France migrated to central Algeria (a wetland at the time) and later were the source of the Atlantis myth after a mud volcano to the south erupted. That's enough to start on, oh, here's a clue to get you going - look to see where the Clovis point stone spearhead migrated to around that time. Obviously you'll need to read the Plato mythology on it too, the Pillars of Hercules were considered to be between Sicily and Africa at the time the original myth was written, not Gibraltar. There's also gentic data on Europedia that can help, it's the later (post 30,000bce) mtDNA X that you'll need to follow. If you assume that the population in Africa got mostly wiped out in roughly 9850bce (aside from a few Berbers that have mtDNA X) you can see that the survivors migrated to the Levant and Greece. Old Sparta was certainly one of those colonies. And Gobekli Tepi as well.
      Only do this is you enjoy the torture though, it's a very deep hole. Just ignore anything written after the Greek about it though.

    • @IamOutOfNames
      @IamOutOfNames 3 года назад +161

      "DON'T GO LOOKING."

    • @ArmaliteSpade
      @ArmaliteSpade 3 года назад +28

      How many cows did that guy own? I don't know! It's just numbers you prick! Write them like a normal person!

  • @bongosmcdongos4190
    @bongosmcdongos4190 3 года назад +7986

    I love how hundreds of years later Hearne is being dumped on by YET ANOTHER popular scholar.

    • @StarDude1
      @StarDude1 3 года назад +304

      A. Pope is amazing

    • @st1220
      @st1220 3 года назад +70

      @@StarDude1 yes he is

    • @Josearnaldomanuel2
      @Josearnaldomanuel2 3 года назад +456

      Well, based on what we've been shown he clearly deserves it.

    • @DavidJoh
      @DavidJoh 3 года назад +217

      Also I'm never ordering copper from Ea-Nasir. His customer service was dreadful.

    • @Iron-Jupiter
      @Iron-Jupiter 3 года назад +205

      Hearne is rolling in his grave that people still haven’t let it go lmao

  • @madelinegolding4969
    @madelinegolding4969 2 года назад +3715

    I’m a PhD student and I just got back from a 7 mile hike turned 16 miles by a wrong turn and, suddenly, the forest of all knowledge analogy just got 1000% more relatable

  • @3srs5U
    @3srs5U 3 года назад +2625

    "This path went absolutely nowhere, provided nothing of value, and drained many hours of my sadly finite life."
    My research mentor said almost exactly the same thing to me years ago, talking me out of pursuing a PhD. Not all heroes wear capes.

    • @wizzotizzo
      @wizzotizzo 2 года назад +7

      Damn.

    • @TheWickedWizardOfOz1
      @TheWickedWizardOfOz1 2 года назад +93

      Was he the world's foremost expert on anteaters, by any chance?

    • @smth.something
      @smth.something 2 года назад +30

      @@TheWickedWizardOfOz1 Ahhh, I see you're also a person of culture

    • @t_ylr
      @t_ylr 2 года назад +40

      There's truly no worse feeling than wasting an afternoon looking thru a pile of dusty old books just to not find what you were looking for. Or even worse to find out that the thesis for your paper is wrong and you have start all over.

  • @MathsOwl2950
    @MathsOwl2950 3 года назад +5407

    Grey: "The poem didn't even make it into the -main video-"
    The "main" video: 2.4 million views
    This video: 3.3 million views

    • @ChaoticEnigma92
      @ChaoticEnigma92 3 года назад +209

      That .2 million is me. I've come back here a lot...

    • @zyaicob
      @zyaicob 3 года назад +68

      Holy mother forkin' shirtballs- this is the main video

    • @dallarian8687
      @dallarian8687 3 года назад +26

      Tbh when I browsed the channel, this video is way more interesting than author's stories about his GF.
      [that's the feeling about videos' content I got; note: English isn't my main languange]

    • @nothernstar2576
      @nothernstar2576 3 года назад +1

      3.2 m already

    • @LeoStaley
      @LeoStaley 3 года назад +11

      @@ChaoticEnigma92 The Tifanny video is now showing at 2.3 million. WTF??

  • @JoshSweetvale
    @JoshSweetvale 2 года назад +13069

    9:00 Alexander Pope literally wrote down: *"To future historians:* This guy's a hack."
    And here *we, future historians,* goggle at his spiteful, beautiful foresight.

  • @TheDramacist
    @TheDramacist 3 года назад +3461

    There once was a researcher named CGP Grey,
    Who whilst hunting Tiffany lost his way.
    A poem's date he did chase, it's source be erased,
    Hearne's antiquarian ways did dismay.

    • @furretar6484
      @furretar6484 3 года назад +76

      I love limericks, thank you

    • @Fightre_Flighte
      @Fightre_Flighte 3 года назад +28

      Thank you, Senpai.

    • @lesscringeymapperdude
      @lesscringeymapperdude 3 года назад +20

      Wow he must be in love with this Tiffany girl

    • @carzman35
      @carzman35 3 года назад +6

      Fricking Limericks are awesome

    • @peaceheis
      @peaceheis 3 года назад +14

      Now time to re-edit it via bad editing and call it out via shade.

  • @ausburne5265
    @ausburne5265 3 года назад +2095

    Grey coercing the viewer to join him in the back rooms is absolutely terrifying.

    • @aturchomicz821
      @aturchomicz821 3 года назад +8

      Yeah...😔

    • @SuperHothead14
      @SuperHothead14 3 года назад +62

      And then they keep scooting back.

    • @DMDarren
      @DMDarren 3 года назад +37

      So Grey is the only one capable of entering and exiting the backrooms at will?
      Pretty selfish of him to be leaving the tens of thousands of people stuck on the various floors of a very inhospitable and dangerous place I must say

    • @ArtIsMySin19
      @ArtIsMySin19 3 года назад +19

      Terrifying yet totally on brand

    • @LittleGoblinBoi
      @LittleGoblinBoi 3 года назад +37

      What do you mean terrifying? I'd be 100% down for that! I'll either get shanked, or get told a story, a win-win situation!

  • @the_flying_airplane5335
    @the_flying_airplane5335 3 года назад +788

    I love the “being held hostage” vibe in this video like he just kidnapped us all to rant about a historian with bad memory

  • @botondstrauss9410
    @botondstrauss9410 2 года назад +6269

    A detailed list of every time Grey mispronounced Scotichronicon:
    5:26 Scotchinomicron
    5:54 Scotchicromicon
    6:05 Scotchironomicon
    7:36 Scotchichronicon
    15:11 Scothrinomicon

  • @Niilomaan
    @Niilomaan 3 года назад +1436

    Most people would be proud to dig up hundreds of years old source. You go on further and manage to fact check it. Amazing work.

  • @kazzar831
    @kazzar831 3 года назад +2065

    One day, I hope Grey writes a book called "The Chronicles of a mad man and his less than auspicious journey through the Forest of All Knowledge" where he documents all of these stories. I would cherish such a book. It would be taught in colleges.

    • @user-svqmbiv
      @user-svqmbiv 3 года назад +64

      That is genuinely something that I would love to have.

    • @anegwa
      @anegwa 3 года назад +78

      And then another person 300 years later can go through a mountain of research and use his book. This is a great idea

    • @JamesDavis-qk4hr
      @JamesDavis-qk4hr 3 года назад +44

      A book like that would be invaluable for teaching people how to research.

    • @cvillan35
      @cvillan35 3 года назад +8

      THIS. THIS IS THE BEST THING IVE EVER SEEN

    • @themudkipmando4125
      @themudkipmando4125 3 года назад +9

      Hexagoneth art thy best-agoneth

  • @Ailorn
    @Ailorn 3 года назад +1927

    This is what "did my research" actually looks like. Snark aside, this journey was incredibly fun to hear about!

    • @sirjoey3137
      @sirjoey3137 3 года назад

      Did you do it? Did you do it? Did you do it, huh? Did you crunch the numbers?

  • @ntsazazel
    @ntsazazel 2 года назад +1911

    As someone who recently fell down a similarly niche rabbit hole of research, this video entirely encapsulates the feeling of being possibly the only person who cares about X subject/question in the modern world. We take Google for granted until it turns up zero results, or when the Wikipedia footnote trail runs dry or lacks any page to begin with. It’s genuinely fascinating to me

    • @jrggrop
      @jrggrop Год назад

      What hole did you fall down?

    • @kjw79
      @kjw79 Год назад +119

      Or days of searching 1400 pages of microfilm on each of a hundred rolls microfilm to find that one land record sentence that proves when your ancestors came to Canada. ❤️ It

    • @ntsazazel
      @ntsazazel Год назад +22

      @@kjw79 This is the sort of stuff I love to see!

    • @kjw79
      @kjw79 Год назад +69

      There were a few photos of great great grandfathers headstone, brown and covered in lichen on the ground. Online cemetery websites shared the same few photos that cropped off the last line.
      There is seemingly no paper records in all the land regarding his origin place in Scotland.
      But behold, one distant cousin found on Ancestry took a snap in the 80s and scanned it to me 40 years later. The last missing line?
      “Native of Kirkcudbrightshire”
      Makes me feel like Indiana Jones

    • @politenonparticipant4859
      @politenonparticipant4859 Год назад +26

      When tracing back the roots of knowledge, inevitably we will either reach bedrock or find the root end snapped, its origin separated by a long forgotten incident or oversight creating a gap in the vast time abyss.

  • @MandosSez
    @MandosSez 3 года назад +2697

    "Ardent STEM stan slowly discovers the Humanities, descending into madness" has been a wonderful plotline so far. Can't wait to see what's in store.

    • @charliespinoza1966
      @charliespinoza1966 3 года назад +16

      +

    • @vortex_master
      @vortex_master 3 года назад +138

      It's been the antithesis of my past 6 months, which has been "Ardent Humanities stan slowly discovers STEM, descending into madness."

    • @imnotahippie22
      @imnotahippie22 3 года назад +12

      I fell asleep twice while watching this. But i did rewatch it after waking up more. Was hard but wanted to watch the whole thing to be supportive in my own way

    • @casey6556
      @casey6556 3 года назад +42

      As someone who studied Math and GRSJ (Gender, Race, Sexuality, and Social Justice) in university and is now studying Law, this comment is deeply accurate and insightful.
      I feel Grey’s pain in my soul.

    • @rsaylors
      @rsaylors 3 года назад +2

      A return to the question of truth.

  • @RJRJ
    @RJRJ 3 года назад +31689

    Thank you for developing unhealthy obsessions with obscure topics for my entertainment

  • @mabimabi212
    @mabimabi212 3 года назад +1023

    "I didn't come to this library to look the earliest reference to Robin Hood."
    Something tells me he will someday

    • @Superhrnet
      @Superhrnet 3 года назад +62

      HE DID! Just after he hinted at it! So he fell down a rabbit hole while down a rabbit hole.

    • @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721
      @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 3 года назад +25

      But that's a story for another time.

    • @johnkieth4537
      @johnkieth4537 3 года назад +15

      @@Superhrnet so while down in a hole he found a cave, poor guy

    • @bretterry8356
      @bretterry8356 3 года назад +11

      I would love to hear his historically accurate take on Robin Hood, with all the romance and mythology stripped away.

    • @childofnewlight
      @childofnewlight 3 года назад +11

      I'd say throw the man a rope, but we'd probably end up with a video on the history of rope making.

  • @qyasar8046
    @qyasar8046 2 года назад +1253

    This took the butterfly effect to the extreme. A few hundred years ago some guy made a fanfic about the scotronomicon and a few hundred years later some random guy is going insane wondering how someone lived 89 years before he was born

  • @TheRekabNivek
    @TheRekabNivek 3 года назад +832

    When people say "I've done my own research", this is the level you have to go to to over turn the experts

    • @TheNerdySkier
      @TheNerdySkier 3 года назад +113

      If they do this level of research, they ARE the expert. Grey is the world’s foremost expert in Tiffanys, there is no doubt in my mind

  • @drizzle7876
    @drizzle7876 3 года назад +802

    When you said: "This script is so long. Is anyone still here?" I nodded and said yes, then forgot you can't see nor hear me.
    I don't know how to feel about that.

    • @richardbloemenkamp8532
      @richardbloemenkamp8532 3 года назад +18

      How could anyone leave such a fantastic story. I had to watch it a second times right after finishing just to make sure I captured all the fun.

    • @elylozada9576
      @elylozada9576 3 года назад +1

      Me as well.

    • @rbitrary
      @rbitrary 3 года назад +4

      Online work really did a number on us, huh?

    • @vanord
      @vanord 3 года назад +3

      Love it when I read the comment section and someone refers to a section of the video at the same time that part is playing

    • @tieshaunntanner6846
      @tieshaunntanner6846 3 года назад

      @Drizzle I did the exact same thing :D

  • @rhythmaich3940
    @rhythmaich3940 3 года назад +1192

    "...provided nothing of value and drained many hours of my sadly finite life."
    CGP Grey is one of the people who deserve to be made immortal.

    • @hellomonkeymiller
      @hellomonkeymiller 3 года назад +28

      I'm not sure if that would be a blessing or a curse for him. :p

    • @jacksonstarky8288
      @jacksonstarky8288 3 года назад +9

      The only problem with immortality is that the human mind really isn't equipped to comprehend its implications. Even our sun has a finite lifespan, and we can't live without it. What happens when the sun goes red giant, possibly incinerating the earth (and definitely making it uninhabitable) in the process? I'm not sure he would want to make that a video topic, though; it sounds like he might find it depressing... but then, after making this video, maybe that wouldn't be an issue for him, given the line that has been quoted above.

    • @kurumi394
      @kurumi394 3 года назад +9

      @Alex Munz with an exit option.

    • @trans_eater
      @trans_eater 3 года назад

      For what purpose?
      He does nothing important.

    • @lordadamantium1210
      @lordadamantium1210 3 года назад +3

      @@jacksonstarky8288 Well, even if we become Immortal, that doesn't mean we can't die. Let's say you become ageless and immune to disease. Let's also say you leave the house everyday for you're job, or on a walk. Eventually, probably within a thousand years you're going to trip and break you're neck. Or die in a car crash, or hell struck by lightning. When you're Immortal, the small percentage chance of dying by any of those things steadily increase until it eventually happens

  • @IsamBitar
    @IsamBitar 2 года назад +6269

    Watched this with my fiancée. We're both PhD researchers and this was just perfect.

    • @EEEEEEEE
      @EEEEEEEE 2 года назад +34

      E‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎

    • @loganfaucher
      @loganfaucher Год назад +45

      That's awesome! What's your PHD in?

    • @rafaelfigfigueiredo2988
      @rafaelfigfigueiredo2988 Год назад +7

      That's sweet man

    • @IsamBitar
      @IsamBitar Год назад +167

      @@loganfaucher mine’s in autonomous vehicles and game theory. Hers is in clinical research and patient reported outcomes.

    • @loganfaucher
      @loganfaucher Год назад +14

      @@IsamBitar that's do cool

  • @SheKnives
    @SheKnives 3 года назад +7491

    What an interesting rabbit hole to fall down in.

    • @Iceglorp
      @Iceglorp 3 года назад +7

      Yes

    • @KudosK42
      @KudosK42 3 года назад +23

      The pains of making a video about a topic that some people or even noone has made before.

    • @fignewtonbar8587
      @fignewtonbar8587 3 года назад +3

      I love your channel btw, your vids with merk are great

    • @chrisbabbitt4202
      @chrisbabbitt4202 3 года назад +29

      Fall down? CCP Grey swan dives into rabbit holes.

    • @Marquis-Sade
      @Marquis-Sade 3 года назад +3

      @@RIPToot Why?

  • @IntetDreamer
    @IntetDreamer 3 года назад +883

    I don’t think I ever actually understood how historians do research until watching Grey. Truly insightful and fascinating. Thanks for all you do to teach the world.

    • @JonatasAdoM
      @JonatasAdoM 3 года назад +11

      I still don't think I do but Mike Duncan does a great explanation of his process somewhere in his Revolutions podcast. I don't think I have ever seen someone else explain it.

    • @TheNord06
      @TheNord06 3 года назад +26

      we historians do have rules and methods, until we hit the decisive madness that is humanity. after that fact we write down is whatever that makes sense chronologically in a cause and effect relationship.

    • @Hallowed_Ground
      @Hallowed_Ground 3 года назад

      @@TheNord06 That sentence is very difficult to read.

    • @Alexander_Grant
      @Alexander_Grant 3 года назад +1

      @@Hallowed_Ground Well he's a historian, not an author, cut him some slack.

    • @TheNord06
      @TheNord06 3 года назад +1

      Also not native speaker, sorry guys.

  • @mega17
    @mega17 3 года назад +1524

    It wasn't for nothing. It is a story about citation, erroneous historians, and your passion for knowledge! Thank you, CGPGrey. :3

    • @iamverita
      @iamverita 3 года назад +35

      It's not for nothing. It teaches a sense of the fragility of information. You can't read a description of the problems a fact check runs into and understand it in the level you can after this video

    • @AdfasSSBM
      @AdfasSSBM 3 года назад +4

      Still, though. It was for nothing

    • @aaronbulmahn3817
      @aaronbulmahn3817 3 года назад +14

      It‘s not for nothing. It teaches about research and how important it is to be accurate for a singly, small mistake might go down in history for hundreds of years.

    • @il6605
      @il6605 3 года назад +4

      Still, though, It was for nothing

    • @michaelblevins346
      @michaelblevins346 3 года назад +3

      Yes!! I teach a research class and will be using this video to show the frustrations that come from tracking sources.

  • @LunaMapping_KR
    @LunaMapping_KR Год назад +1486

    Reading beef between historic writers is the most entertaining thing ever, I would have never knew about this EVER without you Grey

  • @edhamey5737
    @edhamey5737 3 года назад +4052

    There once was a man named Hearne.
    A studious man who wanted to learn.
    With terrible sourcing,
    and errors discoursing,
    after 300 years he still makes people gurn.

    • @magnumsmth
      @magnumsmth 3 года назад +129

      Cut the studious out of the second line and it's perfect
      Except for the last line don't know what to do with that

    • @blueblade6174
      @blueblade6174 3 года назад +27

      Bars

    • @elyay7203
      @elyay7203 3 года назад +15

      Spitting bars

    • @BLiu1
      @BLiu1 3 года назад +56

      @@magnumsmth For centuries he still makes us gurn

    • @bensoncheung2801
      @bensoncheung2801 3 года назад

      269 likes.

  • @ianpotto
    @ianpotto 3 года назад +1294

    I learned absolutely nothing of importance for 20 minutes and loved every second of it. You and your team are a treasure and I look forward to the next meandering excursion into the Forest of All Knowledge, whether there's a destination or not.

    • @TonboIV
      @TonboIV 3 года назад +20

      This is another time for that old Ralpha Waldo Emerson quote:
      "I cannot remember the books I've read any more than the meals I have eaten; even so, they have made me."
      Whether or not we learned anything of importance, just how Grey went about finding that knowledge is very insightful about how our history is kept (and often how badly). This and the Staten island video have made me really think differently about written history and recorder knowledge in general.

    • @inderrai8690
      @inderrai8690 3 года назад +5

      I learned a lot. Trying can be video even if you fail and that could be successful.

    • @BrunoGomes-su1bk
      @BrunoGomes-su1bk 3 года назад

      Amen

    • @SS64DD
      @SS64DD 3 года назад +1

      Didn’t expect to see you here, great job on the 30th anniversary comic!

    • @ratoh1710
      @ratoh1710 3 года назад +4

      I learned that Alexander Pope came up with the phrase, damning with faint praise, so that's something.

  • @QuarterLifeCrises
    @QuarterLifeCrises 3 года назад +730

    As a student who doesn't have my life and finances in any semblance of order, it always warms my heart to hear Grey's insistence that students shouldn't contribute to his channel if they aren't financially stable. Thank you, Grey. Just a couple more years and I hope to join the Bonnie Bee Brigade. In the meantime, I'm watching and re-watching your videos.

    • @grigorijklymenko3198
      @grigorijklymenko3198 3 года назад +24

      Dear Sam I could not agree more. People like that are who inspire us to work towards the success and be rich enough to become patrons ourselves

    • @Soulzzzzz
      @Soulzzzzz 3 года назад +14

      if you are watching, you are contributing

    • @deadbzeus
      @deadbzeus 3 года назад +8

      There are a few channels this being one of them who I definitely plan on donating to when I am done school. It's amazing how much some RUclipsrs do for students now.

    • @theyhave268
      @theyhave268 3 года назад

      Same

    • @kylehardman9135
      @kylehardman9135 3 года назад

      its no better as a museum assistant these tangents are soo easy to make

  • @stevenbuck3753
    @stevenbuck3753 Год назад +1872

    I did watch all the way to the end of the "Someone Dead Ruined My Life... Again." video because I felt a certain shared frustration. I've gotten a lot of laughs from your videos and appreciate all @CGPGrey has done to inform the world.

  • @mcflugglemuffin4548
    @mcflugglemuffin4548 3 года назад +885

    I feel like in 300 years some historian will look back, hopelessly researching some random topic, and find Grey commenting on Hearn and Pope, then spiral even further, seeing Grey as one of the great 21st century historians.

    • @nanszoo3092
      @nanszoo3092 3 года назад +33

      Revenge of the Grey

    • @notmwangi
      @notmwangi 3 года назад +83

      It's interesting how these ancient historians were probably exactly like Grey - hopelessly curious random ppl, and that's the same way he'll be seen. That's why I like your use of "21st century historian"

    • @kittykat490
      @kittykat490 3 года назад +13

      I was having this exact thought while watching... he is now a member of this long line of historians and archivists producing works that show the path back to other older works

    • @angelwhispers2060
      @angelwhispers2060 3 года назад +9

      I hope that RUclips or some of its successors has ported forward these videos by then. Because by their mere existence it will be inferred to some future historian chasing down the same rabbit hole. And in that distant day in the future somebody will write a textbook saying how cgp grey is the most awesome historian of industrial / post-industrial America. And some poor school kid will have to sit around watching video after video of Grey's research that we presently do for fun.

    • @aidendouglas8023
      @aidendouglas8023 3 года назад +4

      I hope to remember grey as we remember Thomas Hearne, as a semi-crazy dude who loved random papers and just put stuff in cause why not

  • @jaspervanheycop9722
    @jaspervanheycop9722 3 года назад +2011

    Hearne was so bad at his job that he literally would've done less harm if he just preserved all the stuff he hoarded and did absolutely nothing else? That's impressive, almost aspirational.

    • @bcubed72
      @bcubed72 3 года назад +212

      I knew a guy like that.
      He was a government employee, and a horrible worker who screwed EVERYTHING up, especially when he was loaded, which was most of the time.
      It was almost impossible to fire him at the time, so they kept getting promoted, to jobs were he did less and less, and ultimately was responsible for nothing.
      The premise was, "if we can make him useless, it will be a huge improvement."

    • @titusjames4912
      @titusjames4912 3 года назад +6

      Reminds me of Arthur Dent.

    • @EtsuMatsuya
      @EtsuMatsuya 3 года назад +55

      @@bcubed72 Oh man, I want that job. Getting paid very well to do nothing is a dream. Getting promoted due to incompitance also a dream. Though, this makes sense assuming it is the US government. Our tax dollars at work. >.>;

    • @djeity
      @djeity 3 года назад +51

      Hearne was far from alone, and his practices and attitude persisted until at least the early 1900s. I have made a minor study of armour (the kind you wear) and quite a few of the most popular Victorian-era sources are, shall we say, hilariously wrong. I suspect that at least part of this is because, these days, we have much readier access to information than at any previous time in history. I am speaking of the free availability of public museums and libraries-of-record, not the Internet, although that too is a combined boon and curse. Many of the worst Victorian sources are tertiary sources (at best), which should underline for you Grey's insistence on primary sources in his research.

    • @scottwilliams895
      @scottwilliams895 3 года назад

      Really gives me hope, as I glance around at all the sh1t laying around my place

  • @error.418
    @error.418 3 года назад +614

    That was the most well-spoken, balanced, and inviting Patreon pitch I've ever heard.

  • @alittlebitd3ad
    @alittlebitd3ad 2 года назад +765

    02:58 I love how it says here that a blonde Tiffany is "practically unknown" but cgp always draws Tiffany as a blondie

    • @max-zv7sf
      @max-zv7sf Год назад +88

      Tiff is the type of girl to dye her hair.

  • @tiffanylynnmcclelland6632
    @tiffanylynnmcclelland6632 3 года назад +978

    As a Tiffany and a historian, these videos have been such a delight. I am sorry you felt alone in this research, but I am thankful and grateful for you and the work you do. I used your videos in my history classroom, and still enjoy watching them as I support others in their teaching endeavors. Thank you!

    • @Rhakjellg
      @Rhakjellg 3 года назад +25

      you ruined this poor mans life. you monster! get out a’here!

    • @neuralmute
      @neuralmute 3 года назад +3

      Have you by any chance read Terry Pratchett's delightful series of books about Tiffany Aching, witch-in-training? They're worth a read for the humour alone, but as a historian, you'd get a lot more out of the references and allusions that Pratchett, amateur historian and folklorist that he was, packed all his works with.

    • @GeoffCostanza
      @GeoffCostanza 3 года назад +4

      Grey wasn't completely alone... Tiffany was with him. She even sang about it.
      "I think we're alone now..."

    • @DonnieX6
      @DonnieX6 3 года назад

      @Joel JinisKalpadikkal Rhakjellg is obviously joking, no worries 😉

  • @sanstheblaster2626
    @sanstheblaster2626 3 года назад +531

    I can almost picture Alexander Pope mocking Thomas in the afterlife about how he polluted history for the future generations, screaming "THIS GUY GETS IT" every time Grey critiques Hearne.

    • @KQuinTN
      @KQuinTN 3 года назад +97

      "Look at this scholar sent on a goose chase because SOMEONE couldn't fact check their work." Alexander Pope.

    • @chrishale5213
      @chrishale5213 3 года назад +22

      When he dissed dude right after he died, I suddenly had more respect for Drill music. Post mortem disrespect has been around a while.

    • @daniwalmsley611
      @daniwalmsley611 3 года назад +6

      I like the idea that pope just starts watching this whenever hearnes about

    • @brettwood1351
      @brettwood1351 3 года назад +19

      If nothing else, this video saves anyone else who ever finds Thomas Hearne as a source a lot of time.

    • @expansivegymnast1020
      @expansivegymnast1020 3 года назад +1

      @@chrishale5213What Alexander Pope did was the 18th century equivalent of putting coin sound effects over the names of every op who died.

  • @dub-jscrub-j2762
    @dub-jscrub-j2762 3 года назад +546

    There's something so cozy and _nostalgic_ to research someone that no one cares about by yourself, knowing that you are the only one that will ever have the experience, and to think about how you revived a person's memory from the dead for just a little bit longer.

  • @VoicelessRabbit
    @VoicelessRabbit Год назад +404

    I keep rewatching this from time to time. This and hexagons are the bestagons are my favorite grey videos for pure enjoyment factors.

    • @rocknikhil5905
      @rocknikhil5905 Год назад +4

      I love the bestagons video.

    • @matgeezer2094
      @matgeezer2094 Год назад +1

      Hexagons are the bestagons is a great video

    • @Inkay257
      @Inkay257 Год назад +3

      I also love those 2, the bestagons are a religion now 😂, but Capt. Billop also deserves a place, it seemed Grey was going to use a oujia board to get an interview with Disoaway

    • @teggplant1539
      @teggplant1539 Год назад +8

      Airport codes squad, where art thou?

    • @spingleboygle
      @spingleboygle Год назад +1

      hexagons are the bestagons

  • @CCNYMacGuy
    @CCNYMacGuy 3 года назад +2939

    Main takeaway: The "Scotichchronicon" sounds like what you might use to conjure up an army of zombie Braveheart cosplayers.

    • @eliserieke9308
      @eliserieke9308 3 года назад +44

      Or something from D&D

    • @jaken6335
      @jaken6335 3 года назад +12

      It looks like it too

    • @Sarsol1989
      @Sarsol1989 3 года назад +52

      Or some eldrich Scotsman... im imagining Cthulhu in a kilt

    • @jamescampbell2353
      @jamescampbell2353 3 года назад +4

      This is an excellent idea

    • @tmurrin1979
      @tmurrin1979 3 года назад +18

      "Did you speak the exact words?"
      "Look, maybe I didn't say every single little tiny syllable, no. But basically I said them, yeah." 😂

  • @outofdarts
    @outofdarts 3 года назад +3922

    We all have our rabbit holes. You're not alone. Great video!

    • @daroldcarold3443
      @daroldcarold3443 3 года назад +1

      Hah lorl

    • @kinseylise8595
      @kinseylise8595 3 года назад +8

      You're right, but I wish mine were as varied and broad as Grey's! As it turns out, there exist only so many articles, books, and papers on the history of Taekwondo...

    • @sirBrouwer
      @sirBrouwer 3 года назад +4

      @@kinseylise8595 there is always a rabbit hole to go deeper in. the question is how deep is deep enough. Like you could dive in to the production of the sports equipment and who make them and why in that (exact) way.
      just keep digging until you don't even know that the start was Taekwondo.

    • @giovanni-cx5fb
      @giovanni-cx5fb 3 года назад +4

      Not everyone, just people worth talking with.

    • @gvs6462
      @gvs6462 3 года назад +2

      How deep is your rabbit hole?

  • @FRDinaMechSuit
    @FRDinaMechSuit 3 года назад +1681

    Whenever someone says, “do your own research” I’m going to show them this video.

    • @fds7476
      @fds7476 3 года назад +46

      To be fair, I've come across _so_ many people sealioning me that I might consider this fate sufficiently schadenfreudig.

    • @saikgamingproductions
      @saikgamingproductions 3 года назад +15

      @@fds7476 Schadenfreude?

    • @fds7476
      @fds7476 3 года назад +12

      @@saikgamingproductions
      Ja.

    • @thebiggestcauldron
      @thebiggestcauldron 3 года назад +10

      @@fds7476 Sealioning?

    • @fds7476
      @fds7476 3 года назад +56

      @@thebiggestcauldron
      Basically when your conversation partner spams you with demands to provide evidence for every little thing you state, and then demands evidence for _that_ evidence, in bad faith - not because he wants to get to the truth of a matter, but purely to annoy and then discredit you.

  • @exachixkitsune5655
    @exachixkitsune5655 2 года назад +592

    I have only just discovered this channel, watched this before the other Tiffany videos, and I am enjoying it so much I let out an exasperated cry at 16:30. Thanks, Hearne.

    • @g_vost
      @g_vost 2 года назад +48

      the drama is real, hearne reached through the ages to specifically troll Grey

    • @Harshiahaha
      @Harshiahaha Год назад +14

      Exactly! I have just discovered this channel, well not 'just' but about some 10 days ago, and felt as if I watched a thriller movie. Again revisiting this video!

  • @pancakefoxp
    @pancakefoxp 3 года назад +847

    As a librarian, this reminded me that work matters. Old dusty books that no one has touched in 50 years allow dedicated people like you to tell us about the past through incredible work, Grey. Thanks for being you.
    And as someone who obsessively researches topics, this is also just really validating and enjoyable to watch.
    Finally, I think you're actually modelling great dedicated research practice, and probably teaching thousands of people how to find sources!! ❤️❤️

    • @Kas_Styles
      @Kas_Styles 3 года назад +10

      Thank you for your work.

    • @Kas_Styles
      @Kas_Styles 3 года назад +5

      And I also love to research.

    • @mmmk1616
      @mmmk1616 3 года назад +2

      Agree with you on all points, brava! I love his content, am willing to wait for it, which he talked a bit about at the end. He is really grateful for his fanbase and patrons, wish I could give.

  • @TheModernMartialArtist
    @TheModernMartialArtist 3 года назад +7243

    Thomas "The Chronological Order Hitman" Hearne.

    • @vercingetorixsonofavernia6598
      @vercingetorixsonofavernia6598 3 года назад +70

      Gotta say, one of the the funniest comments I’ve ever read. Love your channel

    • @ayyguevara8448
      @ayyguevara8448 3 года назад +12

      Please do more Marciano breakdowns I beg you

    • @HS12341000
      @HS12341000 3 года назад +11

      Basically a written chopping right 0_o

    • @totheendandbeyond
      @totheendandbeyond 3 года назад +3

      😭😭😭😂😂😂

    • @THE_ODOUR7
      @THE_ODOUR7 3 года назад +10

      This comment is absolutely legendary

  • @LegoEddy
    @LegoEddy 3 года назад +232

    "This path went absolutely nowhere, provided nothing of value, and drained many hours of my sadly finite life."
    - An honest conclusion of every other phd thesis

  • @katieevans4444
    @katieevans4444 Год назад +154

    I really do love videos like this, they show passion in a way people don’t get to see from creators all the time. Also thank you for telling us to take care of ourselves before taking care of you. Idk I guess I just needed to hear that

  • @RagaarAshnod
    @RagaarAshnod 3 года назад +1564

    When the Necronomicon of Scotland is in a section of a library where the lights are incapable of turning on, you know it's a bad omen.

    • @COLDCHEMICALpresents
      @COLDCHEMICALpresents 3 года назад +145

      “But the plans were on display…”
      “On display? I eventually had to go down to the cellar to find them.”
      “That’s the display department.”
      “With a flashlight.”
      “Ah, well, the lights had probably gone.”
      “So had the stairs.”
      “But look, you found the notice, didn’t you?”
      “Yes,” said Arthur, “yes I did. It was on display in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying ‘Beware of the Leopard.”

    • @OriOfTangleWood
      @OriOfTangleWood 3 года назад +18

      @@COLDCHEMICALpresents this is exactly the passage I thought of when he said the lights were out!!

    • @0Clewi0
      @0Clewi0 3 года назад +10

      I thought that was usual English humor about Schotland.

    • @knz730
      @knz730 3 года назад +16

      That book 1000% has a demon bound to it. I don't make the rules.

    • @nanachichi1044
      @nanachichi1044 3 года назад +2

      I'm still at the 4th book, but I miss those early humour

  • @elijahwerner6130
    @elijahwerner6130 3 года назад +506

    Knowing that there is a library that must be explored, at least in part, by flashlight (would that be torchlight in England?) brings so much joy to my life.

    • @MrWhangdoodles
      @MrWhangdoodles 3 года назад +54

      Kinda brings the idea of fantasy book libraries to life. I imagine Grey as an aging mage looking desperately for an obscure tomb that was though to be lost...I am realizing as I am writing this that I just described Gandalf. Grey is Gandalf.

    • @MajinOthinus
      @MajinOthinus 3 года назад +27

      Do *NOT* use *torches* in a library full of ancient tomes!

    • @destructivforce2894
      @destructivforce2894 3 года назад +27

      @@MajinOthinus You can't stop me!
      *Burns down the library of Alexandria by accident*

    • @catboygremlin
      @catboygremlin 3 года назад +2

      right? like, all of those old books, all of that information! *nerd time*

    • @kuehnjakob
      @kuehnjakob 3 года назад +7

      @@MrWhangdoodles Gandalf the Grey.
      It all comes together.

  • @jewboi2137
    @jewboi2137 3 года назад +578

    WHY, PLEASE WHY, GREY'S RESEARCH PROCESS IS EVEN MORE FASCINATING THAN THE ACTUAL VIDEO

    • @Alex_K221
      @Alex_K221 3 года назад +13

      I know. If I knew where to start, I’d like to go on my own maddening journey into the forest of all knowledge just to track down a footnote.

    • @suvl
      @suvl 3 года назад +1

      This. Exactly this.

    • @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721
      @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 3 года назад +1

      Anyone can make a video. Not everyone can make a video about making a video.

  • @eggmon420
    @eggmon420 Год назад +65

    Imagine someone creating a caricature of you and calling it WORMIUS. Hearne might wanna put some cold water on that huge burn.

  • @TheRedKing247
    @TheRedKing247 3 года назад +680

    Historiography is honestly just as interesting as the actual real history. To figure out how people of the past recorded history and what they got wrong is incredibly meta. Videos like this will always be appreciated.

    • @herpydepth3849
      @herpydepth3849 3 года назад +10

      It’s almost like the history version of zoomers going from playing Fallout 4 to playing Fallout 2. It really is fascinating

    • @anjetto1
      @anjetto1 3 года назад +4

      That is amazing. Do you have any suggestions of videos based around that. I'm fascinated now

    • @artistwithouttalent
      @artistwithouttalent 3 года назад +1

      @@anjetto1 seconded

    • @cameronscott9399
      @cameronscott9399 3 года назад +2

      @@artistwithouttalent thirded

    • @Skyfox94
      @Skyfox94 3 года назад +4

      and I'd say it's also very important. It's sort of a clean up mechanism for history, figure out what was actually true and not random bs is important if we want to truly understand the past.

  • @MangoMotors
    @MangoMotors 3 года назад +348

    The fact that you've actually made this video the most entertaining thing I've seen in weeks speaks volumes to how amazing of a storyteller you are.

    • @green0563
      @green0563 3 года назад

      Agreed. I loved listening to this.

    • @Annemoontje
      @Annemoontje 3 года назад

      This was my favourite video :D

    • @softti4846
      @softti4846 3 года назад

      This man just made me waste 20 minutes of my life on a story of how he went down way to many rabbit holes and I enjoyed every second of it!

    • @ГеоргиГеоргиев-с3г
      @ГеоргиГеоргиев-с3г 3 года назад

      @@softti4846 *too
      And there is no such thing as way too many rabbit holes usually the more you dig the plentiful the bounty.

  • @susanmorris6343
    @susanmorris6343 3 года назад +429

    As a family historian, looking at records from the 1400s, 1500s and 1600s, and so often finding myself on a winding trail which leads me back to the beginning without solving any of the puzzles along the way, I can identify with this so much!

  • @lizzyamaranth4141
    @lizzyamaranth4141 2 года назад +249

    I felt like I was on the verge of dying of laughter for around 5 minutes straight at the beef between two writers from the 1600-1700s

  • @MikMoen
    @MikMoen 3 года назад +801

    Grey shouting in a high screechy voice: "WHEN WILL YOU LEARN, HEARNE, THAT YOUR ACTIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES??"

    • @mathewhill5556
      @mathewhill5556 3 года назад +26

      Alexander Pope is rolling in his grave right now!

  • @viever9158
    @viever9158 3 года назад +2031

    I love how grey pronounces “Scotichronicon” differently every time

    • @icwatto
      @icwatto 3 года назад +34

      sciencetes have foud that it is physically impussble to say it more that once the same way exept for those monks who wrote it

    • @gamistry2947
      @gamistry2947 3 года назад +13

      Skaw-ti-kraw-ni-kawn

    • @TheoHiggins
      @TheoHiggins 3 года назад +28

      The RUclips gods are cruel. I left a near-identical comment over a day before yours and it received no attention, while yours is the second comment I see when clicking on the video. And I'm sure there was another before me, with an equally ill-fated, but identical comment.

    • @fclp67
      @fclp67 3 года назад +7

      @@icwatto reading your comment was painful

    • @yoshi-ky1ic
      @yoshi-ky1ic 3 года назад

      @@icwatto impussble

  • @glenn2687
    @glenn2687 3 года назад +337

    as a student, sometimes it's easy to forget the true meaning of "learning" and "pursuing knowledge" amidst such a rigid educational system. this video is a great reminder of what it really means to learn just for the sake of it. hopefully one day i find my own tiffany rabbit hole. great work grey :D

    • @fraser1614
      @fraser1614 3 года назад +15

      As someone writing my masters dissertation, it's now making me self conscious about all my sources I've used without really questioning where they got things from

    • @loveitftw
      @loveitftw 3 года назад +2

      Man, just be careful though. You don't want to have the tendency of falling into every rabbit hole there is. It's fun as hell, but exhausting. Know when it's enough and don't lose yourself.
      (Speaking from experience)

  • @madmike159
    @madmike159 2 года назад +393

    This video explains Grey's obsession with immortality, it wouldn't be such a waste if his life wasn't finite 😂

  • @WantEpicMusic
    @WantEpicMusic 3 года назад +1013

    "This book hasn't been checked out since 1995" -- I don't have the words to describe how that makes me feel, but it sure does make me feel it. Taking these treks through the forest of all knowledge would be that much more difficult in any other place, but then access to so much of written history is totally why you live in London, isn't it! :P

    • @blessedmomof8
      @blessedmomof8 3 года назад +33

      Never having been in a library without the Dewey Decimal system, I imagine myself looking for one book in that library and coming home with 27, and needing to find a castle wherein to hole up and read them all!

    • @thomasdalton9211
      @thomasdalton9211 3 года назад +1

      +

    • @oliversissonphone6143
      @oliversissonphone6143 3 года назад +13

      1995 was when they digitised the library system and stopped stamping the due date in the back of the book.

    • @samuelsudhof8036
      @samuelsudhof8036 3 года назад +4

      @@oliversissonphone6143 Plus, many more people may have read the book without checking it out.

    • @lvlupproductions2480
      @lvlupproductions2480 3 года назад +2

      No he moved to London mainly just because he felt like living abroad no really that's it.

  • @jaridkeen123
    @jaridkeen123 3 года назад +3258

    I really enjoyed this video. I also think its incredibly important. Someone had to do this research and in the future you saved people time that also might come across the poem.

    • @Hoxeel
      @Hoxeel 3 года назад +235

      Fifty years from now:
      "SO MY ONLY SOURCE... OF THIS ENTIRE TIFFANY A-N-Y THING... WAS THIS WEIRD VIDEO ON THIS ANTIQUATED WEBSITE"...

    • @maxnibler6090
      @maxnibler6090 3 года назад +66

      I gotta be honest. I don't know if anyone "had" to do any of this. But I'm glad he did

    • @Junebilation7900
      @Junebilation7900 3 года назад +3

      1kth like!

    • @Nukepositive
      @Nukepositive 3 года назад +67

      And there's more evidence about how unreliable a source Thomas Hearne was. That will definitely come up again.

    • @wiselettuce8715
      @wiselettuce8715 3 года назад +22

      Yep, in the next 200 years, there would've been about...3 people who would stuck on this poem if not for him.

  • @TheRadicalOneNG
    @TheRadicalOneNG 3 года назад +1582

    The *SASS* of Alexander Pope is the most amazing thing ever. Roasting dudes even after they're dead

    • @DuranmanX
      @DuranmanX 3 года назад +46

      If he were alive today he could be a rapper

    • @bjrn-oskarrnning2740
      @bjrn-oskarrnning2740 3 года назад +103

      I think that's called "cremation"

    • @OwnFall420
      @OwnFall420 3 года назад +67

      Announcer: Thomas Hearne is dead
      Announcer: BUT WAIT HERE COMES CGP GREY FROM THE TOP ROPE

    • @maicoxmauler2825
      @maicoxmauler2825 3 года назад +29

      @@DuranmanX If Hearne was alive he'd run a drama channel with a cartoon avatar

    • @MattsAwesomeStuff
      @MattsAwesomeStuff 3 года назад +26

      Alexander Pope is my spirit animal. My life is surrounded by a plague of Hearnes.

  • @SecretAsianMan2222
    @SecretAsianMan2222 2 года назад +89

    I understand your immense frustration, but I absolutely love this. The explination of your research process and the things you find along the way are honestly just as interesting as the final videos you make. Thank you for taking the time to making a video for this rant, totally would watch more of these.

  • @legoboy468
    @legoboy468 3 года назад +555

    Someone in 100 years is going to fall down this same rabbit hole snd be extremely happy that this video exists. Your work is never wasted grey!

    • @csanadhorvath
      @csanadhorvath 3 года назад +6

      no one cared for 300 years prior to this (thus no one fact and source checking this poem), so I doubt that with today's sped up generation, and especially ones that follow, anyone will care about little things like this in 100+ years.

    • @d3adxb0yxwalk1ng
      @d3adxb0yxwalk1ng 3 года назад +18

      @@csanadhorvath you're fun at parties aren't you

    • @ThePrinceofParthia
      @ThePrinceofParthia 3 года назад +8

      Unfortunately, they will only find this video after finding the truth themselves.

    • @kaizokujimbei143
      @kaizokujimbei143 3 года назад +6

      @@csanadhorvath Party pooper. -_-

    • @someplant5971
      @someplant5971 3 года назад +1

      @@csanadhorvath you underestimate the stupidity of the human race

  • @sevenaries
    @sevenaries 3 года назад +961

    The fact that Grey was actually able to track all this down is insane.

    • @vaclav_fejt
      @vaclav_fejt 3 года назад +17

      You can also leave out the words "The fact that was actually able to track all this down" and it's also true, by now.

    • @vaclav_fejt
      @vaclav_fejt 3 года назад +9

      @@dmpmomof3
      1) I'm not saying Seven's writing is wrong
      2) I did mean "by now", that was not a goodbye. Or was that comma superfluous? I can't always tell in English.

    • @fii_89639
      @fii_89639 3 года назад +2

      @@vaclav_fejt Given that one of the books in question is the Scotichronicon, I can totally believe that.

    • @WittAllen
      @WittAllen 3 года назад +1

      To me, a lot of the fascination stems from being able to convey it all back to an audience cohesively.
      I have no problem following rabbit trails all day; thanks, Wikipedia! Realizing I'm on a rabbit trail, orienting myself, document where I am, where I've been, and where I need to go are all incredibly difficult for me.

  • @GetToKnowNature
    @GetToKnowNature 3 года назад +330

    This was glorious. The animator deserves a bonus for the incredible range of emotions they can express through stick figures. And yes, I'm one of those people who loves seeing behind the scenes so thank you for the hilarious to us (but agonizing for you) details of the journey.

  • @RoundusMongus
    @RoundusMongus 2 года назад +78

    3:45 "I opened it, and out fell an old map" A wonderful start to an adventure!

  • @ernestosalinas1091
    @ernestosalinas1091 3 года назад +296

    This demonstrates that I don't need to do a big thing to be remembered. I just need to get my writings in an archive and Grey will eventually stumbles upon those in some very specific research

    • @chelle5900
      @chelle5900 3 года назад +34

      Put something in publication with wrong details. You'll be remembered for centuries

  • @aditiiyer649
    @aditiiyer649 3 года назад +361

    I love how he explicitly mentioned
    “STUDENTS DO NOT PAY”

    • @-ism8153
      @-ism8153 3 года назад +16

      It feels very… Honorable to guide people towards their best interests even if that means not funding more of your work.

  • @GambitsEnd
    @GambitsEnd 3 года назад +550

    Don't worry Grey, something of value DID come out of your journey. We got this fantastic video and a hilarious mini story of two writers feuding.

  • @Michael1.24
    @Michael1.24 2 года назад +95

    The real Tiffany was the friends we made along the way

  • @1943rfagan
    @1943rfagan 3 года назад +6788

    Let's be honest, if Alex pope watched this video today he'd probably be laughing his ass off at Hearne continuing to fail 300+ years later.

    • @TheBluePhoenix008
      @TheBluePhoenix008 3 года назад +140

      Honestly smh

    • @inthe_a.m.
      @inthe_a.m. 3 года назад +63

      truly 😭

    • @tfflus8572
      @tfflus8572 3 года назад +215

      Personaly i have watched the video 10 times becouse it is super funn to listen to grey spiral into madnes

    • @lostboytwo1734
      @lostboytwo1734 3 года назад +9

      True

    • @MLarce9
      @MLarce9 3 года назад +12

      Best comment ever!!!
      I busted out laughing 😂😂😂😂

  • @leftonred11
    @leftonred11 3 года назад +315

    watching the Hearne/Pope thing feels like that feeling when you read a 300 comment argument between 2 strangers that happened 10 years ago on some music video you found by chance

    • @iprobablyforgotsomething
      @iprobablyforgotsomething 3 года назад +26

      *sheepishly raises hand* Guilty. I literally just did this earlier today. I cut myself off way later than I should have, time-wasted wise, yet still before I saw the final comment in the chain.

    • @ethribin4188
      @ethribin4188 3 года назад +11

      Perfect modern comparison.

    • @bryanp9878
      @bryanp9878 3 года назад +6

      like that argument under the paper mario sticker star soundtrack?

    • @whatever6100
      @whatever6100 3 года назад

      @@bryanp9878 which track

    • @traci_angels3549
      @traci_angels3549 3 года назад

      This video explaining the "side-trails" ended up being just as interesting as the original project. Awesome video. Your hard work is appreciated

  • @HelloIAmJo
    @HelloIAmJo 2 года назад +4200

    One of my favorite things is accidentally finding beef between two academics in the form of writing that is ultra-professional.
    When I was trying to find a citation for a single sentence in a paper that I was writing, I found beef between two scientists about phylocode that had been going back for THIRTY YEARS in PEER REVIEWED JOURNALS. I spent a week reading more into it and ended up not even using anything related to my original idea in my final paper.

    • @hindenburg2006
      @hindenburg2006 2 года назад +70

      ...who were the scientists?!

    • @HelloIAmJo
      @HelloIAmJo 2 года назад +282

      @@hindenburg2006 it’s about phylocode. The main ones that I was referencing were Dr. Kevin de Quieroz and the late Dr. Norman Platnick.

    • @hindenburg2006
      @hindenburg2006 2 года назад +74

      @@HelloIAmJo thanks! I now have some nerding to do😊

    • @irgendwieanders2121
      @irgendwieanders2121 2 года назад +7

      I feel you :-)

    • @baconofthedarkside
      @baconofthedarkside 2 года назад +167

      If you want a computer science beef, specifically in the field of random number generators, there's a minor feud between Melissa O'Neill and Sebastiano Vigna where they argue *a bit* about whose random number generator is better, and it even ends up with arguments in GitHub repositories in the form of issues raised with the code, where one of them complains that the other's random number generator is being used in fairly popular open source libraries.

  • @monnaak
    @monnaak 2 года назад +170

    I honestly want you to make more of these "AYO ALL THE PROBLEMS AND SIDE PATHS I ENCOUNTERED WHILE MAKING THE TIFFANY VIDEO" videos. They're so much fun for nerds like us

  • @Xp_Iggy
    @Xp_Iggy 3 года назад +2026

    0:57 The way Grey says "Don't go looking" is filled with such tired agony, you just know how many hours he has lost because he went looking.

    • @joed527
      @joed527 2 года назад +17

      Those lost hours give us hope that our own "quests" can be fruitful.

    • @malistraja5944
      @malistraja5944 2 года назад

      That is called a rabbit hole

  • @jmlkinc
    @jmlkinc 3 года назад +267

    The point I broke out laughing is when he got to the Scotichronicon. Which just sounds like a tome used to summon kilted zombies.

    • @jmlkinc
      @jmlkinc 3 года назад +34

      OK, now I'm at the point where he finally found a historian he could call and talk about this all over coffee with, only to realize he's been dead for over 125 years. Amazing.

    • @depdava1
      @depdava1 3 года назад +5

      it (Actually) summons kilted elder gods from beyond time and space. :)

    • @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721
      @vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 3 года назад +3

      @@jmlkinc Maybe Grey should try using the book to summon his zombie.

  • @AtelmGoldsmith
    @AtelmGoldsmith 3 года назад +707

    As an archivist, this delve into old records and libraries has really brightened my day. More of these, please, Grey! :)

    • @AndyZach
      @AndyZach 3 года назад +10

      Are you an antiquarian?

    • @justanotherhuman.3649
      @justanotherhuman.3649 3 года назад +17

      /Hoarder

    • @Call-me-Al
      @Call-me-Al 3 года назад +11

      As a layman, I bloody love videos like this.

    • @GeneralPet
      @GeneralPet 3 года назад +1

      We are enjoying his suffering :D Though I'm sure he gets something out of unearthing this hidden information to the public.

  • @David-gh1hj
    @David-gh1hj 2 года назад +38

    You are a ridiculously tenacious researcher, and I, for one, appreciate all your efforts.

  • @DarkVortex97
    @DarkVortex97 3 года назад +1390

    Grey's videos often give me this existential terror of the sheer weight of all human knowledge that no person alive has given a second thought to. How many books and letters and poems have been lost to time. How many names and records and deeds have been lost or are about to be lost to a coffee spill or termites or mold.
    Christ, we don't even have a complete history of the big picture stuff if you go back more than 1000 years.

    • @olevam1
      @olevam1 3 года назад +49

      And even less than that if we leave the Euroasian land mass

    • @MegaVidFan1
      @MegaVidFan1 3 года назад +17

      The feeling gets less scary the older you get. Just learn what you are easily able to, no one can know anything else.

    • @Cbd_7ohm
      @Cbd_7ohm 3 года назад +4

      The great leap forward.

    • @user-ow2cs7fb5l
      @user-ow2cs7fb5l 3 года назад +5

      Yes

    • @TacomaJak
      @TacomaJak 3 года назад +48

      In addition to losing pieces, its pretty fked how some ppl deliberately cut information out of books, or just don’t care about preserving knowledge. Like id be so pissed to be those yr 1300 monks after writing my version of the complete history of the universe for some dude in the 1700s to edit and cut how he saw fit.

  • @spikeslobodian
    @spikeslobodian 3 года назад +1632

    man from 1700s: "learning more about this poem is a waste of time"
    grey: "better go deeper"

  • @Jesse__H
    @Jesse__H 3 года назад +349

    Your efforts were no waste of time, they were _historical scholarship!_ Which is always endless hours resulting in one tiny but *TRUE* thing being added to our collective knowledge.
    You have done real work here, and I thank you for it. 🙏

    • @OwnFall420
      @OwnFall420 3 года назад +30

      Absolutely. I also learned Alexander Pope was a murderer with words, and Thomas Hearne is rolling around in his grave as we speak.
      Still the dedication Grey puts in is astounding

    • @kingofgar101
      @kingofgar101 3 года назад +9

      Returned to our knowledge for a brief moment before misquoted or lost into obscurity until at some point in the future another grey could dig it up again

  • @RatBasterd
    @RatBasterd Год назад +28

    This is honestly one of my favorite videos. As someone who has fallen down more rabbit holes than I care to think about, I really appreciate the effort you put into your work. Thank you for all you do.

  • @IngramZero
    @IngramZero 3 года назад +189

    In the RPG " Call of Cthulhu" one of the great dangers was going insane researching by reading ancient tomes, and here is a video of it happening. Great video an pretty fascinating, and thank you for the effort put in this.