Can someone help me here. In this case there something that bothers me all the time. 1) When intruder approaches anyone and is armed with a gun is it possible that someone can stand up and start fighting the intruder who is holding a gun? 2) When such happens can the intruder just shoot one person and leave others to live to tell about the murder? 3) Can some intruder holding a gun ask money and cellphone and then allow someone to pass through. Especially in that small house because whoever is intending to leave the house and going outside has to pass through the intruder, and being 2 intruders for that matter. These questions remain unanswered. If it really happened like that. The hit men were so poor in doing their task and the late victim can we say he was so stupid to put himself in such danger? We can here many theories but common sense says a man with a gun cannot be under estimated to a point of fighting him with bare hands.
I have the same question, and another intruder was next to the door (by the window) with a Gun and the two Twalas (Longwe first and Mtho after) just run pass him.
My hypothesis, Longwe hired and knew these on behalf of himself and Kelly. No wonder he could walk out. Longwe messed up everything by calling these guys prematurely before people left the house. But Longwe was so posed off to see the guy who had spent the night with his gf still in the company and he blamed it on Senzo whom i suspect was also chowing Zandie. Kelly and Longwe wanted Senzo dead. Just that Longwe acted on impulse of his drugs and totally messed up everything. His courage and walking out give Senzo and other guys a sense of false bravery. No one else was meant to be killed... no cell phone or money was meant to be robbed
@@LujoSey You sound very right. Honestly, I have seen many videos of people being eliminated by hit men here in SA. Senzos way is different. I cam across a certain article written by someone who knows much about nkabis, he said Senzo Meyiwa was not killed by an inkabi but there is something that went wrong and people who where in the house are not willing to devulge. But Gininda knows something as well. Baloi knows something as well.
The key person in this case is Kelly khumalo in terms of her being Senzo's girlfriend she was the reason for Senzo to go with her to her Mom's house. 1. Why did Baloyi not summoned her as a witness? Senzo was driven to hospital in his car. Why was the car not swiped? 3. All those who were in that house clothes and their hands were not swiped for the gun powder, Why? 4. The hit men don't ask for phones their only assignment is to kill and leave . Why would this suspects shoot only one person? 5. If Kelly khumalo is the master mind, why was she not arrested when these suspects were arrested? 6. We know that Baloyi was supposed to take that decision. Why didn't he issue out that warrant of arrest? 7. We also know that Baloyi is related to Chicco Twala and that's why he refused to summoned Longwe Twala to court as a witness. 8. We know that Kelly called Chicco twala first instead of Senzo's family, Why? 9. We also know that Chicco twala offered Kelly khumalo a holiday trip overseas said Madlala the same night Senzo was shot at. Why? We know that Kelly khumalo refused to handover Senzo's car and other belongings to his family, Why? We know that Kelly khumalo did a sim swipe on Senzo's phone, Why? Lastly why most of the police officers who were involved in investigating this case were killed and the police show no interest in finding their killers?
Don't worry about Mnisi the defense are working together, other issues will be dealt with by Nxumalo and Mshololo these advocates do discuss their way of questions and remember Ngomezulu is watching U Tube he's coming back with a bang 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👋
@mpendulodlamini1813 I would think Mnisi is Gininda nightmare. Try to think logically. Can scientific evidence be better than witnesses like Zungu who were not even at the crime scene. DNA and phone records say Mncube wasn't there physical description is questionable. Can dreads grow longer in 3 minutes and there is no evidence of gold tooth. Makeleng saw a tall person with dreadlocks and a gold tooth
Gininda is a liar and he can't help himself and somehow I think he doesn't know that as a public we are watching and we are paying attention to everything
Which one you regard as a lie? Also help the same public, what is acrual the truth.? Why can't you go help the defense and be their witness so you can tell the truth. 😂😂
@@bongilakey1019 he knows very well but it matters not because they are used to doing this with impunity and no consequences. I'm certain if you go through his cases, you will see the same trend of telling lies and defeating the ends of justice
When he colorate,he said Zungu said he saw suspect number 3 in the hostel but the State said Zungu has being told by his father.Constable Zungu said he was with the accused,but Baloyi change it that , constable was told by his father.Aii
Spent a week cross examining, only to be bruised and battered the strongest on the last round. I dont think buzehla ubuthongo today kule ndoda. Ibethiwe strong.
@kennethobyani1848 you have said it all my brother. It’s done with them. Mnisi thot by shouting and disrespecting Gininda will change the evidence before Ratha, its evident that these are the killers of Senzo
It stinks to high heavens. An average person would be dark and dark brownish, they cooked up a story then went looking for people who fit the description.
That stupid judge is a true reflection of the caliber of judicial officers in this country. Imagine such an imbecile being an entire judge. We should be ashamed of ourselves as a country
You can call him names all you want but he is educated and a qualified Judge😂 He is presiding on this case. The fact that you support the 5 murders who are currently doing time for different crimes, including murder but that doesn't mean Ratha is not deserving to be a Judge. 😂😂 Those 5 are going for a very long time. Maybe you will be dead if they ever come out alive.
Mnisi has been on podium for 2 weeks saying nothing proving nothing. The defense is failing dismally hence mnisi is making so much noise. Gininda is going to be a great lawyer
@@SiyabonaDyaloShow me on what police standing orders is that. Please Sir give us some facts. Gininda say this more than 100 times. That when police going around on the street in any part of the world they don't carry warnings statements with them. it's only completed when the police are processing the suspects for the court. Please don't be like Mnisi. He is busy asking questions but he do not even understand what is he asking about. That is why Gininda has embark on an educational tour. You can't be alwayer and half of the questions you're asking you even don't understand it your self. That is why he keep asking 2 questions for the rest of the day.
😂😂😂 talking about stupid Gininda😂😂 Gwabini and Makhosonke are coming as Defense witness to dispute fake statements that said by stupid hitman Gininda 😂😂 unfortunately Simphiwe pased away but walikhuluma iqiniso court Simphiwe 😂😂😂
One question, Ginindza gives 20 lines answer. No DNA for accused persons. Ballistic Expert Lady said Student (Mr Mangena) got it all wrong. IO says the open bag that had the weapon at Police station, its integrity is compromised. Crime scene cleaned. Ntanzi interviewed by IO without warning statements, eye witnesses says the weapon guy is dark with gold teeth. Accused 3 phone is in JHB, IO wants us to believe he left his phone. IO went and told Magistrate for a fact that the weapon/ pictures on Acc#3 phone is definitely the murnderr weapon. He says its because he is a trained SAPS member. Short dreadlocks were spoted by eye witnesses, prev suspect was identified and released, now they are pointing this one😮😮. Accused 3 has long dreadlocks. IO says maybe he changed dreadlocks in one day from short to long. 😅😅. #ReleaseTheBoys.
Two suspects have confessed and put Kelly Khumalo as the person who hired them. The confessions have been accepted by the court as being real. The third suspect has agreed that it is him who is on those photos. The judge has allowed the defence the chance to challenge all of these facts, which is why Gininda is answering to questions about issues that have been admitted to be true before the court. Now accused 3 appears to be denying to know accused 1& 2! The cellphone analysts have linked Kelly Khumalo with the other accused through cellphone records. Confessions are what led to the case being changed to being a hit, and not a robbery. Now advocate Mnisi as a representative of accused no 3 is doing his best to extricate accused 3 from the confession mess, even though the accused has agreed that it is him on the photos. I think that if the judge sticks to these facts he will be accused of being partial, which could be why he allows the defence the time". He is the ultimate arbiter and he has accepted the confessions as being credible evidence. Now my question is what is the aim of the prosecution when it didn't charge miss Khumalo ??? This is an intriguing part . . . .". To me the honourable judge Ratha appears to be patient enough to allow everyone the chance deserved before he makes the final decision on all the facts oresented to him.
To answer to your question and this is my opinion. Remember there were plea deal negotiations between Ntanzi and the state. Mjiyako and Mshololo were part of those negotiations according to Gininda during the trial within a trial. This evidence was never rebutted. So , those negotiations collapsed because Ntanzi as he was going to turn a state witness, never agreed to a number of years he should serve as a result and he therefore retracted or withdrew his confession. So it was going to be difficult for the state to arrest Kelly Khumalo without these confessions by either Ntanzi or Muzi. So i think this is the reason the prosecution team advised Gininda to dig more as there was not enough evidence against her and fortunately the confessions are now accepted by the court. Kelly definitely will be arrested after the state is done with the 5 accused.
Ratha loves gininda to bits he is so happy when gininda talks and ratha just allows him to go on and on say anything h3 wants. He allows gininda to run his court and control the proceedings as and how he sees fit. Nobody must tell gininda nothing he gets very upset. Ratha is happy and smiling when gininda talks. Does ratha even understands gininda's explainations. I wish one of the defense can ask ratha to repeat what gininda's explanation let's see if ratha remembers
@@colinvadival6004he even failed to tell if the accused had a gold tooth or not instate he went on to explain nonsense, I couldn't even here what he was trying to explain.
It's so funny though how people claim Gininda is lier yet they agree with him when he say Kelly is the mastermind, at the same time they claim that these accused are innocent, tell me who was hired by Kelly to commit the offence if these accused are innocent?
I personally say if he'saying Kelly involved why is she not arrested, he claim NPA are in charge of that he still investigating but people are already infront of judge how so?
She didnt hire anyone she did the job herself. Longwe told Adv Teffo that (Longwe) arrived at the Khumale residence with his fathers revolver. As told she shot him (Senzo) by mistake. The police official who visit first after the incident told them they must say there were 2 intruders. The cooking starts there
@@LedwabaJohannesDo you have evidence to prove that Kelly was the mastermind? The state had nothing to prove except the confessions which were later retracted by Ntanzi and Muzi. This is the reason the prosecution said they should go and dig more and im happy now because Gininda said they have found another evidence even though he didn't say the details.
It looks like muthi, sangomas and witch doctors play a strong role in ratha's court room. He denies having knowledge of it being used to assist in the South African court but I think he's using it too therefore his behavior stinks
🤔 Yeeeereh this guy never answered any questions,he is asked about something he puts the whole docket in record and repeats one thing in different ways
@normannetshamutavha7691 🤔ya he has tried so far but has left a lot of arguments,he cannot account to important aspects of the investigation , like he was outside looking in
This case was centered around Mnisi's client and he failed spectacularly for 2 weeks to prove that accussed 3 was not in Vooslorus on the 26th Oct 2014, he was not having dreadlocks and not wearing a beige jacket. Morover, 9mm pistol was seen in one of accused 3 pictures. Accused 3 used to deny knowing other accused, but today he claims he knew accused 4 and 5
Just like Judge Ratha u Quoting what you see fit for you Mnisi is taking gininda step by step,vodacom removed from the crime scene ,the hat that was said he was wearing doesn't have his DNA ,the state has failed to prove their case nje 😅
I am not sure why people are acting so dumb not to see what's going on in this case or perhaps, they hv an interest or Gininda's shomis? There is a prima facie evidence in the form of Avl & it was read by Pinkie proving dat the accused were not in Vosloorus during the time of an incident😂
@@levelgroundboerboels4183Gininda and Baloyi are bunch of crook and liers. Now their lies cought with. Is there any normal person who can say a phone can walk without its owner shame on Gininda 🤣🤣🤣👍
Wat the state is doing in our country and the judgement system of which judicial powers are used for individual interests or benefits 😢😢😢 10 year's wonke niyanya Baloyi ,ngifuna ukubona lekhehla liyothini ngoZulu wethu😢😮
Useless defence ..they must first tackle the toture dat led to confession...koz these were totured into signing .so this defence won't come out of this
You can't deal with torture in the High court. You pass magistrate court and regional court. That case must be withdrawn there. Mshololo was there in lower court why she didn't fight for the accussed as she is fighting now. her self and Mjiyakho and Baloyi. please do t make us stupids.
That's what eye witness evidence is - shud it be 100% identical, then it wud be considered to be tailor made. We may see the same thing, seeing it differently. Others may not even see it at all!!!
Constable Zungu said they were drinking beer from 15:00 when he arrived until they disappeared and came back to the hostel, so photos downloaded from accused 3 says from 17:28 he was in Johannesburg 😂😂😂Zungu is misleading the court together with his state friends.
Ya vele it is impossible that the suspects appearance will remain the same given that they have been in prison for a long time ,so sibenecompie. I love the way Brig. Gininda is presenting his evidence
This defense team is confused. According to Mngo it was Longwe who shot Senzo and he intend calling Kelly as a witness 😂😂 According to Mshololo is was Kelly who mistakenly pulled the trigger😂😂 So , Kelly is both a suspect and a witness at same time? This is a true display of naked amateurish by the defense.
Remer my brother, that a suspect is armed does not mean that he automatically will win and not mean that you may not take a risk to overpower him. It is up to you to take that risk or not if u dare enough to confront him, u can take that risk. I remember the other man who was confronted by two offenders, one was armed with a gun and the other with a knife. The victim quickly grabbed the armed man and overpowerd him by taking the gun and the other suspect ran away
Gininda can't afford to lie in the court as most seem to suggest , doing so would get him in unnecessary trouble , he's guided by the evidence from Kelly ,Zandi ,Longwe & Tumelo.
Go and watch interview of a guy who was arrested for murder of Shabalala in KZN ... He's out bcos real killer committed suicide and he wrote a suicide note ... Those police that lied are still as free as a bird
Someone please correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't Longwe alleged to have sent an sms around 6pm or just before 7pm to say he's outside? According to Kholobarate, Senzo was shot around 8:30pm. That means Longwe was in the house for over an hour. Yet Tumelo said Longwe walked past them as he was outside, smoking, and he didn't greet them. Then they went back into the house and "kwaqala umsindo". I think these timelines are very important
Why was Hlophe's cellphone records not investigated in order to prove who lied between him and Tumelo. If Tumelo lied then CAS 636 is indeed a cover up. How did Mjiyakho actually know about Ntanzi's incarceration, only through the please call me? Where is Mjiyakho's cellphone record, did he actually call Ntanzi ? How did Ntanzi get to pay Mjiyakho? Where is proof? How long did Ntanzi manage to remain with his cellphone in the cell as per the allegation? How was the 9mm retrieved by Gininda from ballistics?
As for me I feel sorry for these guys because they’re going to be sentenced for something that they didn’t even do or have knowledge of it according to me the judge is already taken his decision about this matter you can tell the way he is taking side
Seemingly you don't know suspects and their lawyers, these guys know everything about this incident, the lawyers here are only fighting for their wallets they know the truth as well
And Ratha is excitedly buying the stupid assertion. I'm a dark skinned African male whether it's early in the morning, midday or night. I can't understand why accused 3 will be many different skin colors in one day depending on what time it is.
Coz he's already took his decision and he knew that the lawyers will go further to the constitutional court or any higher court then this bt judge ratha already usebagwebile labasolwa special Mncube and Ntanzi and Fisokuhle Ntuli Sbiya and accused no4 bazothola uswazi oluncane kakhulu futhi u no 4 angase adedelwe ngesexwayiso
Which case are you watching?😂😂 All these photoes was not taken at Voslorus and Mncube since he was born was light..so now Stupid Gininda shift to Mncube about gold teeth 😂😂😂
So, he runs out through the same door where intruder we standing not minding the gun. and after the gun went off the intruders also runs out! Now Longwe finds help and he come back to help not knowing whether the intruders have left!
I still have a question why mr zungu the police officer was invited to witness the fire arms and outfit exchanging and the introductions by the accused Who can intentionally invite a cop before planing to commit crime In crime scene was this accused bragging by his golden teeth
What is the outcomes of FFC04415/20/20? COZ I see gone mute now, who was an Attorney Practisìg or account as own , Director, Partner, sole owner and an Advocate operating
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 kininda, his trying so hard to place those boys at the scene of crime 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 what is prudent, my lord 😂😂😂😂the more his trying, more and more he drift away from the truth and the core of his case
Ya mthethu wena ungakubuka ku impossible, but the fact is that it happens that u confront the suspect braverly an remember that a criminal wheather is armed or not, they only thing about win and they are sometimes stupid in their actions and diverted from it easily
I agree with you same as when the evidence is against the accused then it is cooked and only when the gun has a wheel or revolver, that evidence is not cooked 😂😂
Can someone help me here. In this case there something that bothers me all the time. 1) When intruder approaches anyone and is armed with a gun is it possible that someone can stand up and start fighting the intruder who is holding a gun? 2) When such happens can the intruder just shoot one person and leave others to live to tell about the murder?
3) Can some intruder holding a gun ask money and cellphone and then allow someone to pass through. Especially in that small house because whoever is intending to leave the house and going outside has to pass through the intruder, and being 2 intruders for that matter.
These questions remain unanswered. If it really happened like that. The hit men were so poor in doing their task and the late victim can we say he was so stupid to put himself in such danger? We can here many theories but common sense says a man with a gun cannot be under estimated to a point of fighting him with bare hands.
Real truth
I have the same question, and another intruder was next to the door (by the window) with a Gun and the two Twalas (Longwe first and Mtho after) just run pass him.
My hypothesis, Longwe hired and knew these on behalf of himself and Kelly. No wonder he could walk out. Longwe messed up everything by calling these guys prematurely before people left the house. But Longwe was so posed off to see the guy who had spent the night with his gf still in the company and he blamed it on Senzo whom i suspect was also chowing Zandie. Kelly and Longwe wanted Senzo dead. Just that Longwe acted on impulse of his drugs and totally messed up everything.
His courage and walking out give Senzo and other guys a sense of false bravery. No one else was meant to be killed... no cell phone or money was meant to be robbed
@LujoSey they left a BMW X6 and ran on foot that's another thing that raised eyebrows for the cops. I am with you 100% nice analysis
@@LujoSey You sound very right. Honestly, I have seen many videos of people being eliminated by hit men here in SA. Senzos way is different. I cam across a certain article written by someone who knows much about nkabis, he said Senzo Meyiwa was not killed by an inkabi but there is something that went wrong and people who where in the house are not willing to devulge. But Gininda knows something as well. Baloi knows something as well.
The key person in this case is Kelly khumalo in terms of her being Senzo's girlfriend she was the reason for Senzo to go with her to her Mom's house. 1. Why did Baloyi not summoned her as a witness? Senzo was driven to hospital in his car. Why was the car not swiped? 3. All those who were in that house clothes and their hands were not swiped for the gun powder, Why? 4. The hit men don't ask for phones their only assignment is to kill and leave . Why would this suspects shoot only one person? 5. If Kelly khumalo is the master mind, why was she not arrested when these suspects were arrested? 6. We know that Baloyi was supposed to take that decision. Why didn't he issue out that warrant of arrest? 7. We also know that Baloyi is related to Chicco Twala and that's why he refused to summoned Longwe Twala to court as a witness. 8. We know that Kelly called Chicco twala first instead of Senzo's family, Why? 9. We also know that Chicco twala offered Kelly khumalo a holiday trip overseas said Madlala the same night Senzo was shot at. Why? We know that Kelly khumalo refused to handover Senzo's car and other belongings to his family, Why? We know that Kelly khumalo did a sim swipe on Senzo's phone, Why? Lastly why most of the police officers who were involved in investigating this case were killed and the police show no interest in finding their killers?
Don't worry about Mnisi the defense are working together, other issues will be dealt with by Nxumalo and Mshololo these advocates do discuss their way of questions and remember Ngomezulu is watching U Tube he's coming back with a bang 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👋
Gininda is a defence worst nightmare 😅
I have a question where is the gold tooth on accused 2 and 3
Insangu izonibulala nobabili liphi izinyo legidr
@mpendulodlamini1813
I would think Mnisi is Gininda nightmare. Try to think logically. Can scientific evidence be better than witnesses like Zungu who were not even at the crime scene. DNA and phone records say Mncube wasn't there physical description is questionable. Can dreads grow longer in 3 minutes and there is no evidence of gold tooth.
Makeleng saw a tall person with dreadlocks and a gold tooth
He is an excellent witness. He is on point with procedure and understanding of the law
Gininda is a liar and he can't help himself and somehow I think he doesn't know that as a public we are watching and we are paying attention to everything
Which one you regard as a lie? Also help the same public, what is acrual the truth.? Why can't you go help the defense and be their witness so you can tell the truth. 😂😂
@@bongilakey1019 he knows very well but it matters not because they are used to doing this with impunity and no consequences. I'm certain if you go through his cases, you will see the same trend of telling lies and defeating the ends of justice
When he colorate,he said Zungu said he saw suspect number 3 in the hostel but the State said Zungu has being told by his father.Constable Zungu said he was with the accused,but Baloyi change it that , constable was told by his father.Aii
@levelgroundboerboels4183 he is lying about the gun. In fact, the entire identification is orchestrated
Gininda is an excellent witness. He even understands the law way better than Mnisi.
The nice thing about the case is that we are spectators, whatever is said on media doesn't affect the court.
So bakithi keep typing....
😂😂😂
As the court pleases my lord 😂😂😂
Lothi mnisi omoshe nsuku eziningi for nothing yena wenzani unyaka wonke
Never mind that team Gininda
Gininda on point 👍👍💯
You drunk during the week
As always 👌
You are being accomplice
He can lie with a straight face ...... Sis🚮🚮
BUT those 5 murdered Senzo, lied a lot but now it catch up with them. They are going for a long time
how does the device move on its own 🙃 c'mmon please sibadala for this ntsomi..
Same as the runaway phone that went to the hostel.
Lol Mnisi can't find the documents hence he said he will bring them after lunch. Booooommmm after lunch no documents found. Mnisi is a joke
Spent a week cross examining, only to be bruised and battered the strongest on the last round. I dont think buzehla ubuthongo today kule ndoda. Ibethiwe strong.
Bhaloy is leading investigator and prosecutor
I agree with you
Brigadier Gininda is hitting the final nails on the coffin of accussed 3. I see another life sentence on this one. Ntanzi is already in, Binnekant
@kennethobyani1848 you have said it all my brother. It’s done with them. Mnisi thot by shouting and disrespecting Gininda will change the evidence before Ratha, its evident that these are the killers of Senzo
Phakathi phakathi, that's where Ntanzi belongs😂😂
@Wele1012 The overwhelming evidence is there even Steve Wonder and Bhabsy Mlangeni can see it. Lezinkabi will never ever see sunlight again.
Tsek with your hired Judge
@@ateam7904 Now why use the vulgar???
It stinks to high heavens. An average person would be dark and dark brownish, they cooked up a story then went looking for people who fit the description.
That stupid judge is a true reflection of the caliber of judicial officers in this country. Imagine such an imbecile being an entire judge. We should be ashamed of ourselves as a country
@@floydmamekoa8725 𝚟𝚎𝚛𝚢 𝚊𝚜𝚑𝚊𝚖𝚎𝚍 𝚊𝚜 𝚏𝚊𝚛 𝚊𝚜 𝚒𝚗𝚝𝚎𝚛𝚗𝚊𝚝𝚒𝚘𝚗𝚊𝚕 𝚜𝚝𝚊𝚗𝚍𝚊𝚛𝚍𝚜 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚌𝚘𝚗𝚌𝚎𝚛𝚗𝚎𝚍 𝚘𝚞𝚛 𝚓𝚞𝚍𝚒𝚌𝚒𝚊𝚕 𝚜𝚢𝚜𝚝𝚎𝚖 𝚒𝚜 𝚊 𝚌𝚒𝚛𝚌𝚞𝚜🎪. 𝙲𝚒𝚝𝚒𝚣𝚎𝚗𝚜 𝚌𝚊𝚗 𝚗𝚎𝚟𝚎𝚛 𝚋𝚎 𝚜𝚊𝚏𝚎 𝚠𝚑𝚎𝚗 𝚕𝚊𝚠 𝚎𝚗𝚏𝚘𝚛𝚌𝚎𝚖𝚎𝚗𝚝, 𝙽𝙿𝙰, 𝙳𝙿𝙿, 𝚓𝚞𝚍𝚐𝚎𝚜 𝚊𝚗𝚍 𝚖𝚊𝚐𝚒𝚜𝚝𝚛𝚊𝚝𝚎𝚜 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚊𝚕𝚕 𝚌𝚛𝚘𝚘𝚔𝚜 𝚊𝚗𝚍 𝚌𝚛𝚒𝚖𝚒𝚗𝚊𝚕𝚜 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚖𝚜𝚎𝚕𝚟𝚎𝚜.
Very true he is clearly one sided..how many pple passed through Ratha languishing in jail 4 nothing
He has painted a bleak and dull image to already tainted image of Judiciary He is just there to add the stat of these circus
You can call him names all you want but he is educated and a qualified Judge😂 He is presiding on this case. The fact that you support the 5 murders who are currently doing time for different crimes, including murder but that doesn't mean Ratha is not deserving to be a Judge. 😂😂 Those 5 are going for a very long time. Maybe you will be dead if they ever come out alive.
@ateam7904 true, what was once a respected position in the judiciary, has become such a questionable role player in the quest for justice
The level of this case is too huge for the defence. team. .try the Magistrate courts
Mnisi has been on podium for 2 weeks saying nothing proving nothing. The defense is failing dismally hence mnisi is making so much noise.
Gininda is going to be a great lawyer
Ginindza interviewed suspects without warning statements. Boom.
@@SiyabonaDyaloShow me on what police standing orders is that. Please Sir give us some facts. Gininda say this more than 100 times. That when police going around on the street in any part of the world they don't carry warnings statements with them. it's only completed when the police are processing the suspects for the court. Please don't be like Mnisi. He is busy asking questions but he do not even understand what is he asking about. That is why Gininda has embark on an educational tour. You can't be alwayer and half of the questions you're asking you even don't understand it your self. That is why he keep asking 2 questions for the rest of the day.
You are a slow somebody 😅
Speaking fluent English doesn’t mean you’re great or clever…
Empty tin makes more noise
😂😂😂 talking about stupid Gininda😂😂 Gwabini and Makhosonke are coming as Defense witness to dispute fake statements that said by stupid hitman Gininda 😂😂 unfortunately Simphiwe pased away but walikhuluma iqiniso court Simphiwe 😂😂😂
Mnisi trying to be funny but the judge is not finding him funny at all. Nearly there nearly there my lord wat nonsense is that???
One question, Ginindza gives 20 lines answer. No DNA for accused persons. Ballistic Expert Lady said Student (Mr Mangena) got it all wrong. IO says the open bag that had the weapon at Police station, its integrity is compromised. Crime scene cleaned. Ntanzi interviewed by IO without warning statements, eye witnesses says the weapon guy is dark with gold teeth. Accused 3 phone is in JHB, IO wants us to believe he left his phone. IO went and told Magistrate for a fact that the weapon/ pictures on Acc#3 phone is definitely the murnderr weapon. He says its because he is a trained SAPS member. Short dreadlocks were spoted by eye witnesses, prev suspect was identified and released, now they are pointing this one😮😮. Accused 3 has long dreadlocks. IO says maybe he changed dreadlocks in one day from short to long. 😅😅. #ReleaseTheBoys.
Thanks, this is well put.
How do you change dread locks?
Mnisi is found wanting and he's clueless 🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈
Two suspects have confessed and put Kelly Khumalo as the person who hired them.
The confessions have been accepted by the court as being real.
The third suspect has agreed that it is him who is on those photos.
The judge has allowed the defence the chance to challenge all of these facts, which is why Gininda is answering to questions about issues that have been admitted to be true before the court.
Now accused 3 appears to be denying to know accused 1& 2!
The cellphone analysts have linked Kelly Khumalo with the other accused through cellphone records.
Confessions are what led to the case being changed to being a hit, and not a robbery.
Now advocate Mnisi as a representative of accused no 3 is doing his best to extricate accused 3 from the confession mess, even though the accused has agreed that it is him on the photos.
I think that if the judge sticks to these facts he will be accused of being partial, which could be why he allows the defence the time".
He is the ultimate arbiter and he has accepted the confessions as being credible evidence.
Now my question is what is the aim of the prosecution when it didn't charge miss Khumalo ???
This is an intriguing part . . . .".
To me the honourable judge Ratha appears to be patient enough to allow everyone the chance deserved before he makes the final decision on all the facts oresented to him.
Uyavakala kakhulu
Can I ask if this picture are placing accused 3 in a crime scene ,where did they get this pictures and why so many changed statements just asking
Which side are you with so much insight and time on this app?
To answer to your question and this is my opinion. Remember there were plea deal negotiations between Ntanzi and the state. Mjiyako and Mshololo were part of those negotiations according to Gininda during the trial within a trial. This evidence was never rebutted.
So , those negotiations collapsed because Ntanzi as he was going to turn a state witness, never agreed to a number of years he should serve as a result and he therefore retracted or withdrew his confession.
So it was going to be difficult for the state to arrest Kelly Khumalo without these confessions by either Ntanzi or Muzi.
So i think this is the reason the prosecution team advised Gininda to dig more as there was not enough evidence against her and fortunately the confessions are now accepted by the court.
Kelly definitely will be arrested after the state is done with the 5 accused.
@@ateam7904 I am on the side that seeks justice.
Ratha loves gininda to bits he is so happy when gininda talks and ratha just allows him to go on and on say anything h3 wants. He allows gininda to run his court and control the proceedings as and how he sees fit. Nobody must tell gininda nothing he gets very upset. Ratha is happy and smiling when gininda talks. Does ratha even understands gininda's explainations. I wish one of the defense can ask ratha to repeat what gininda's explanation let's see if ratha remembers
@@colinvadival6004he even failed to tell if the accused had a gold tooth or not instate he went on to explain nonsense, I couldn't even here what he was trying to explain.
@@lebomahase3997I can promise you one thing I don't think any person can understand a word this man speaks
He seems to be afraid of him
Finally Mnisi is done 🎉🎉🎉
It's so funny though how people claim Gininda is lier yet they agree with him when he say Kelly is the mastermind, at the same time they claim that these accused are innocent, tell me who was hired by Kelly to commit the offence if these accused are innocent?
I personally say if he'saying Kelly involved why is she not arrested, he claim NPA are in charge of that he still investigating but people are already infront of judge how so?
She didnt hire anyone she did the job herself. Longwe told Adv Teffo that (Longwe) arrived at the Khumale residence with his fathers revolver. As told she shot him (Senzo) by mistake. The police official who visit
first after the incident told them they must say there were 2 intruders. The cooking starts there
@@quanetteStephanusYou are listen to that gossip lawyer called Thulo?
@@LedwabaJohannesDo you have evidence to prove that Kelly was the mastermind?
The state had nothing to prove except the confessions which were later retracted by Ntanzi and Muzi.
This is the reason the prosecution said they should go and dig more and im happy now because Gininda said they have found another evidence even though he didn't say the details.
Mxm
It looks like muthi, sangomas and witch doctors play a strong role in ratha's court room. He denies having knowledge of it being used to assist in the South African court but I think he's using it too therefore his behavior stinks
🤔I like it when the witnesses keep on repeating the colours of the top, brown, khaki and beige are 3 different colours
🤔 Yeeeereh this guy never answered any questions,he is asked about something he puts the whole docket in record and repeats one thing in different ways
And his strategy is working for him because the defense gets frustrated...
@normannetshamutavha7691 🤔ya he has tried so far but has left a lot of arguments,he cannot account to important aspects of the investigation , like he was outside looking in
This case was centered around Mnisi's client and he failed spectacularly for 2 weeks to prove that accussed 3 was not in Vooslorus on the 26th Oct 2014, he was not having dreadlocks and not wearing a beige jacket. Morover, 9mm pistol was seen in one of accused 3 pictures. Accused 3 used to deny knowing other accused, but today he claims he knew accused 4 and 5
Just like Judge Ratha u Quoting what you see fit for you Mnisi is taking gininda step by step,vodacom removed from the crime scene ,the hat that was said he was wearing doesn't have his DNA ,the state has failed to prove their case nje 😅
@@KhayaMahlnagu-yv8so you wrong
I am not sure why people are acting so dumb not to see what's going on in this case or perhaps, they hv an interest or Gininda's shomis? There is a prima facie evidence in the form of Avl & it was read by Pinkie proving dat the accused were not in Vosloorus during the time of an incident😂
Your level of dullness is on another level
Since the case start, 3,4,5 r friends way back
It's very difficult to defend these guys ay
Nothing defficult it's now difficult for Gininda and Baloyi because now all the case they has done must be scrutize
@@everbote7858😂😂😂 Yabheda wen
@@everbote7858Stupid you. Blaming Gininda and baloyi in defence of hose 5 killers. Those idiot deserve to be in jail forever
@@levelgroundboerboels4183Gininda and Baloyi are bunch of crook and liers. Now their lies cought with. Is there any normal person who can say a phone can walk without its owner shame on Gininda 🤣🤣🤣👍
😂😂😂@@everbote7858
Mnisi said he's coming with the bomb 💣 where is it?
I wish they could show us pictures of accused 3
Wat the state is doing in our country and the judgement system of which judicial powers are used for individual interests or benefits 😢😢😢 10 year's wonke niyanya Baloyi ,ngifuna ukubona lekhehla liyothini ngoZulu wethu😢😮
The judge can disagree with defence in everything but when they ask to adjourn ,he does not object .
We are the dominice litis .Please Nxumalo was suggesting that it's almost recess and therefore we must comeback next year. Allegedly
😂
I cannot understand Mnisi arguments because the defence is pleading alibi.
2:19:34 - 2:23:45 Kholobarate talking nonstop. Mr Jonas is a legend! Having to listen to this guy and interpret whatever he's saying.
Brigadier Gininda is competence personified🙌. Our SAPS was is properly represented here
Accused 3 is more lighter because of prison cells. He is the one who killed Senzo. Thanks Gininda
😂😂😂 you are lying accussed was born light 😂😂you believe stupid Gininda shame on you he said Ntanzi had gold teeth now he is sayin is Mncube 😂😂😂😂
@@KZN-p3sstop calling people stupids yet you are an idiot.
@@KZN-p3sdid you grow up with him to know that he was born light skinned?
@@tshililomelvinnekhavhambe3601 yes I grew up with him doing same grades up until university
The accused alleging they don't know each other just seems like a regrettable mistake. And it destroys all their credibility
Useless defence ..they must first tackle the toture dat led to confession...koz these were totured into signing .so this defence won't come out of this
You can't deal with torture in the High court. You pass magistrate court and regional court. That case must be withdrawn there. Mshololo was there in lower court why she didn't fight for the accussed as she is fighting now. her self and Mjiyakho and Baloyi. please do t make us stupids.
Out of curiosity: One of the intruders dropped his hat. There is no way that hat has no hair in it. Whose DNA is on that hair?
@@ezaius2011 Makhumalo's DNA is on that hat she touched it .Allegedly
Maaka a ga mr praaaya to that a npherosa dibete,how do they sleep agggg😡
If there were intruders the people who were in the house could give the same description. Everyone has his/her version
That's what eye witness evidence is - shud it be 100% identical, then it wud be considered to be tailor made. We may see the same thing, seeing it differently. Others may not even see it at all!!!
Even the the judge you can see is very disappointed by the performance of the defense
Mxm you crazy shame yaz 😂😂😂you must be disappointed in yourself 😂😂😂
@@KhayaMahlnagu-yv8so why?
You talking about a biased Judge the one who is captured 🤔
Because vele he dont like them
The judge is corrupt with Gininda and Baloyi bevikela uLongwe owadubula uSenzo 🤞🏽 iqiniso
Sies Mnisi is arrogant
Accused 5 ke ipotsa o rekelwa ke Mang di fabiano
It may happen it's her money that he left outside
English is cruel. Mnisi is confused
Tsek
Insults won't help. Mnisi is useless
Ding dong
English has never been cruel Dom kop wise up
Constable Zungu said they were drinking beer from 15:00 when he arrived until they disappeared and came back to the hostel, so photos downloaded from accused 3 says from 17:28 he was in Johannesburg 😂😂😂Zungu is misleading the court together with his state friends.
Mr Gininda know what he is doing bravo my chief you are not deter by stupid questions
You are so dull
With all the lies😂😂😂
Trust the judiciary at your own stupidity. Criminals amok
Ya vele it is impossible that the suspects appearance will remain the same given that they have been in prison for a long time ,so sibenecompie. I love the way Brig. Gininda is presenting his evidence
Adv Mnisi,thank you for bringing the light to us beyond difficulties it doesn't matter anymore we know have proper clue of how this case was cooked
Mnisi is very weak and has failed to break Gininda
Where is Mngomezulu, really cannot still be sick. Did he drop his client?
Never
He is on standby to investigate every new evidence they bring to court
He need to be in court to defend his client in court. Mngome must come to court and stop investigating. The police has done investigation.
@@zwelimkhize3071 uweee 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Mr Mnisi likes short adjournment 😂😂
This case will still be on till end of Next year.Kelly and family will still have to take the stand
This defense team is confused. According to Mngo it was Longwe who shot Senzo and he intend calling Kelly as a witness 😂😂
According to Mshololo is was Kelly who mistakenly pulled the trigger😂😂
So , Kelly is both a suspect and a witness at same time? This is a true display of naked amateurish by the defense.
We are on day 2 of December. 29 days to 2025.
Ziyaxoxa izinkabi zihleba ukuthi uGininda sizomthola as they can instigate crime inside prison
Your Gininda is a great lier change statements now and again
ginza is going to throw soooo many people under the bus
Accused number 3 muhle mara kodwa yazi. Crime kodwa ....I'm referring to the other crimes that he's sentenced for. Aaai
Remer my brother, that a suspect is armed does not mean that he automatically will win and not mean that you may not take a risk to overpower him. It is up to you to take that risk or not if u dare enough to confront him, u can take that risk. I remember the other man who was confronted by two offenders, one was armed with a gun and the other with a knife. The victim quickly grabbed the armed man and overpowerd him by taking the gun and the other suspect ran away
Gininda can't afford to lie in the court as most seem to suggest , doing so would get him in unnecessary trouble , he's guided by the evidence from Kelly ,Zandi ,Longwe & Tumelo.
Go and watch interview of a guy who was arrested for murder of Shabalala in KZN ... He's out bcos real killer committed suicide and he wrote a suicide note ... Those police that lied are still as free as a bird
@@ColeCollinsCostance1673-q7l He is mainly guarded by the confessions which have been accepted as being credible.
@taoteching7784 what are you trying to say?
Gininda is not shy with his long sermon
Thank you Brigadier Gininda we done for the day 👏👏👏👏👏
This level of dullness is out of this world... ndimwe achipuba
@@voiceofjustice-pm😂😂😂😂😂😂
So someone from the suspects was wearing a hat but when they tested DNA on that hat, it had no DNA of any of the suspect...🤔🤔🤔
Someone please correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't Longwe alleged to have sent an sms around 6pm or just before 7pm to say he's outside? According to Kholobarate, Senzo was shot around 8:30pm. That means Longwe was in the house for over an hour. Yet Tumelo said Longwe walked past them as he was outside, smoking, and he didn't greet them. Then they went back into the house and "kwaqala umsindo".
I think these timelines are very important
Why was Hlophe's cellphone records not investigated in order to prove who lied between him and Tumelo. If Tumelo lied then CAS 636 is indeed a cover up. How did Mjiyakho actually know about Ntanzi's incarceration, only through the please call me? Where is Mjiyakho's cellphone record, did he actually call Ntanzi ? How did Ntanzi get to pay Mjiyakho? Where is proof? How long did Ntanzi manage to remain with his cellphone in the cell as per the allegation? How was the 9mm retrieved by Gininda from ballistics?
I remember Zandi ku interview saying the accused they were wearing face musks
We are dealing with what is said in court and not lensumansumane yakho
This guy doesn’t get tired of talking
The case its scary, from judge to the state prosecutor ,brigadier, and the accused .something it's fishing here.
As for me I feel sorry for these guys because they’re going to be sentenced for something that they didn’t even do or have knowledge of it according to me the judge is already taken his decision about this matter you can tell the way he is taking side
Seemingly you don't know suspects and their lawyers, these guys know everything about this incident, the lawyers here are only fighting for their wallets they know the truth as well
@@NduraaNgomaweeeee
@Ndu Ngoma !u r so much wrong,😂😂😂😂those guys don't know nothing about Senzos death
Essays essays essays !!! Why brigadier? Stop this man from explaining
Gininda is a STAR
He is a crook and lier
He really is a "DESASTAR"
What kind of star 😒😒😒
Shady star
Star of Dumb pple combined together
Now Gininda is a sunlight expert.
And Ratha is excitedly buying the stupid assertion. I'm a dark skinned African male whether it's early in the morning, midday or night. I can't understand why accused 3 will be many different skin colors in one day depending on what time it is.
Why this judge is mentioning ‘this f this case goes somewhere’
What is it that he knows😂😂😂
Coz he's already took his decision and he knew that the lawyers will go further to the constitutional court or any higher court then this bt judge ratha already usebagwebile labasolwa special Mncube and Ntanzi and Fisokuhle Ntuli
Sbiya and accused no4 bazothola uswazi oluncane kakhulu futhi u no 4 angase adedelwe ngesexwayiso
In my view dis judge is crook
Just how many people died, who were supposed to be witnesses?And how did they die?
Mnisi fail to remove his client from the crime scene
The state fail to prove accused number 3 was at the crime scene
Yes thy failed
State failed dismally 😂@@Luphindo
DNA already removed him
Which case are you watching?😂😂 All these photoes was not taken at Voslorus and Mncube since he was born was light..so now Stupid Gininda shift to Mncube about gold teeth 😂😂😂
Gininda talks too much and the Judge seems so protective of him
So, he runs out through the same door where intruder we standing not minding the gun. and after the gun went off the intruders also runs out! Now Longwe finds help and he come back to help not knowing whether the intruders have left!
Gininda does not answer questions only but gives long sermons
CORROBORATE CORROBORATE CORROBORATE CORROBORATE
CORROBORATE CORROBORATE
Brigadier, Not COLLOBORATE
What a waste of time by adv Mnisi
I still have a question why mr zungu the police officer was invited to witness the fire arms and outfit exchanging and the introductions by the accused
Who can intentionally invite a cop before planing to commit crime
In crime scene was this accused bragging by his golden teeth
Why is this still on going?
U dd well Mr mnisi 🎉
We want those warning statements gininda.bcoz u say there are different ones
The incident took place aat night,the neighbour is trying to corroborate the evidence of the people that were in the house.
99percent of witnesses are police officers why not people in the house? Bcos Baloyi, NPA,sithole, Cele and Ratha are diffenting someone
They are relying on circumstantial evidence more than anything. That is a mountain to climb.
What is the outcomes of FFC04415/20/20? COZ I see gone mute now, who was an Attorney Practisìg or account as own , Director, Partner, sole owner and an Advocate operating
Mybe Mnisi is still busy with his investigation.
Namehlo amakhulu😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 kininda, his trying so hard to place those boys at the scene of crime 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 what is prudent, my lord 😂😂😂😂the more his trying, more and more he drift away from the truth and the core of his case
You can not say accuse number 3 is the one you 2 you are apart of that Metter
The device was traveling alone...it came with accuse no 3 and it went back home alone..🤣🤣🤣 sho Brigadier...
Ratha sokubhekele njalo siyi south Africa 😅
The the the the the the😂😂😂😂
A gun Toddler..... Phela a toddler is a kid
A "gun toter" is someone who is carrying a gun, especially a pistol, usually for criminal purposes.
Ya mthethu wena ungakubuka ku impossible, but the fact is that it happens that u confront the suspect braverly an remember that a criminal wheather is armed or not, they only thing about win and they are sometimes stupid in their actions and diverted from it easily
when it suits Gininda it is the device that leaves for Jhb but its the accused when tower places him in Volsorus ..how does thiswork , mr Gininda
I agree with you same as when the evidence is against the accused then it is cooked and only when the gun has a wheel or revolver, that evidence is not cooked 😂😂
I believe defence is winning this case, no reasonable doubt is placed by dtate only hearsay
Accused they didn't know each other? The uccused they were not in Jozi? I wonder how they will justify that😮
Mnisi sit down🎉