@@sjt4225 Not according to the Netflix doc. It says that he was found guilty of manslaughter. The prosecution didn't like losing though so they went around the ruling of the esteemed judge and found someone that would overturn her ruling.
@@geordiewishart1683 He's dead. Hence rest in peace. He is resting (not moving) and he is at peace (his suffering has ended). His religion has nothing to do with it. Has anyone come back from the dead and told you anything different? I didn't think so.
2:40 He certainly deliberately tried to end someone's life of the other side of that door. It was delibrate homicide, but he was claiming that it was ‘self defence’ before anyone attacked him. That was not self defence, which was the reason why he went straight to jail. 🤷
Again - YOU know nothing of the horrendous attacks and murders which take place on a daily basis in South Africa. Trust me - you would shoot first if in the same predicament. @@D-throne
@@miramaric4383 NOBODY claimed self defense. Oscar claimed from the very beginning that he thought it was an intruder. BIG difference. Also - minor detail which has escaped you - they had both been asleep - there was no rage.
His poor girlfriend can't go out and live her life. Her parents have been robbed of their grandchildren as well. How many people on holiday with their wives and children shoot a gun through the bathroom door when they wake up and see a light on in their holiday apartment, toilet. Ridiculous story
He knew full well who was behind that door - and that’s precisely why he fired off 4 rounds. Had it been an intruder locked in the bathroom, all he needed to do was call the police as that person was no of no threat at the stage to the lying Pistorius.
@@josimpson7999not in South Africa. The police are hardly reliable and it’s a very violent country. You would expect an intruder there to be armed and be prepared to shoot. However he should have verified where Reeva was before he shot the first round. IF he genuinely thought there was an intruder and he’d have called out her name she would have called back - unless she had reason to be scared and was hiding from him.
He's an intentional murderer. Plain and simple. He should be in prison for rest of his life. However, it is what it is and if he must live free I pray he lives good and doesn't hurt anybody else. How the system can not see what we all see i don't know. May reeva rest in peace x
Why would a robber hide in a locked bathroom hiding. You’d be stealing the tv downstairs. Even so you wouldn’t shoot 4 times. Fact that she locked herself in the bathroom says a lot about his demeanour
Why wouldn’t he have checked where Riva was before shooting through a door.He sounds an arrogant,entitled man.Riva was probably hiding and terrified from his controlling moods.These people can be charming one minute and mean and vicious,the next.He should not have been released.I hope women steer clear of him.
Why must an intruder lock himself/herself in bathroom? Doesnt make sense. This pistorious is a psychopath unable to deal with his challenges and has ptsd and killed a woman senselessly.
He should NEVER have been released. I predict he will not comply with his parole conditions and will revert to type and will be rearrested. He’s a MONSTER.
If your partner isn’t in bed at night they’re either in the toilet, getting a glass of water or outside having a cigarette. His story doesn’t make sense
Should have rotted in jail. He can now live in comfort, why he's victim's parents must grieve for the rest of their lives. You take a life, you lose your life.
Off the topic: Why mention that the judge was black? I'm just curious if there was a reason, bc he didn't say if the judge was a woman or a man...but that it was a black judge.
He's simply anticipating someone suggesting that he received preferential treatment due to his race. It's more likely he was able to "sway" the justice system with his status and means to hire skilled/learned attorneys and PR personnel. He'd always maintained his original defense, and his legal counsel probably played on any lingering doubts regarding his guilt.
Hello, my comment is out of concept, but I just noticed, Mr. Carlin has forgotten a cigarette on his right ear, which I find a pleasant and authentic ritual of a writer 🤓
He lived in a security complex and an intruder would not be likely. Secondly, I don't know where this man lived in South Africa but the picture he paints is misleading. Crime is high and police are corrupt but there are plenty of safe places to live. I live in a walled non gated community in South Africa and do not even have an alarm system. We don't want people like him implying that South Africa is extremely dangerous. Glad he's gone.
I also lived in a gated community with high security in the Western Cape. No burglar bars, no safety gates, no alarms, sleeping with open gates...until a gang started targeting us, average 4 houses per night, even if you were inside you would wake up with them around your bed. After we all installed burglar bars, safety gates, alarms with armed response they still came in by shattering a non opening window with a spark plug. This only stopped when we started our own night patrol, and then 80% moved out of the complex. There is no such thing as a safe complex in South Africa
I went to SA 20 years ago, walked from my Hotel to the shopping Mall, 2 clicks (stretch the legs and get the vibes), everyone FREAKED out, I thought ....get a life.
He definately was an abusive boyfriend thats for sure, and i personally believe he shot through that door in anger knowing reeva was in there. No can know for definate because we werent there, but thats my belief. But south africa is constant paranoia and looking over your shoulder. I left for that reason. Fed up of bars and gate's and fear
He was jealous of his girlfriend and I think she was thinking of leaving him he would not let her go that why he shoot her. No respect for him he should have done the full prison sentence. He felt he was better than others just because he was a blade runner. God will judge him.
Stop confusing Justice system with Justice or Truth or fairness. Its just a system often haphazardly administered. Sometimes innocent people go to jail, other times guilty people are set free, or never get charged in the first place. Its not uncommon for innocent people to plead guilty to avoid legal costs & stress especially if they cannot afford lawyers (so prosecutors intentionally draw out the proceedings). Oscar by staying home has to pay for his own lodging, the state saves about $200,000 (in the USA) per prisoner.
I do not believe he knew it was his girlfriend. I believe he was confused and fearful. He thought there was an intruder. I believe the "woman's" scream the neighbor heard was his unnaturally high voice.
@@davidg3944 Two witnesses, who lived closer to him (next door) than the witness claiming they heard a woman's scream, both testified it was a man they heard scream. The witness who claimed they heard a woman scream, lived almost 600feet away. An acoustics expert at the trial testified that a woman's scream from inside the locked toilet, could not be heard 600 feet away. They also testified that a hysterical man's scream and a woman's scream, are indistinguishable. Know the facts of the case before you make such childish comments.
@@ScottyEire Ah, the Tooth Fairy appears as a character witness. Character witless is more like it... You're welcome to believe in anything you'd like, the facts of the shooting make it absurdly reckless at best, planned criminality at worst (and in actuality). But stamp your feet if you feel like it, perhaps it'll stop you from kicking your dog.
The world at his feet... What feet? His parents had them chopped of above the knees when he was a baby. Think how he must have felt and the heroic amount of effort and courage his successes must have cost him. It's easy to patronize for all of us with two complete legs.
Stop assuming / justice has taken its course whether you like it or not! This man has to live with his conscience whether clear or not. No one is perfect and it’s not for you to cast judgement! Leave it to his creator! Find peace within yourselves!
The most ridiculous story I ever herd, what would YOU do if you thought some one was in your bath room in the middle of the night ? I would go get my loved ones and exit as fast as possible, not go get my gun and fire into a closed door bathroom hoping to hit something, or maybe just leave and call the cops , ect...Common sense folks. I love moose, and I have a head of one mounted on my wall ?
I think the answer would be 'No' to both questions. I don't think people outside of SA understand the thousands of horrendous crimes which take place on a daily basis in South Africa.
It depends, right? If you live in South Africa or even the United States, your first reaction very well may be to go get your gun. I don't know anything about this case, but from the facts laid out here in this short video, if indeed Pistorious thought there was an intruder (big "if" there), then yes, he may have reasonably gone to grab his gun first since, from what it sounds like, he is missing his lower limbs and may have doubted his own ability to fight off an intruder. Why he didn't say fist, "Honey, is that you?" before firing, I do not know, but maybe she was out that night and he didn't expect her. Or maybe he assumed she was sleeping in a different room. I imagine he was asked that queetion by police and/or prosecutors. But what I can tell you is that we have a lot of guns here in the US, ptobably about 1/3rd to half our population owns at least 1, and we have many very tragic incidents occur involving the shooting of the self or another, many including children getting a hold of improperly secured firearms. If this guy was prosecuted in the US or SA, him grabbing his gun first may not have stood out as odd a behavior as it does seem to be in the UK.
No, and No , but he was already proven guilty in a Court of LAW! So what are you defending ? you want a retrial ?You have no argument what so ever.shooting threw a closed door is like shooting in a crowd and you should not be able to touch a gun with that stupidity period.@@priscillazietsman1300
He should have served a full life sentence. Shameful miscarriage of justice.
Unfortunate that you actually believe that. This was an accident without a shadow of a doubt.
@@thenotorious9032 No. He was found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
@@sjt4225 Not according to the Netflix doc. It says that he was found guilty of manslaughter. The prosecution didn't like losing though so they went around the ruling of the esteemed judge and found someone that would overturn her ruling.
@@ninalescher6650 The judge was NOT esteemed. He murdered that woman in cold blood.
Not only did he end his girlfriend's life, he also utterly destroyed the lives of her parents. Her father is now resting in peace.
…with his beloved Reeva.
May they both RIP 🙏
@@josimpson7999 ❤️✝️😔
Why do you say RIP?
Do you know that this comes from a Catholic prayer for the dead?
Reeva was Christian, not Catholic.
@@geordiewishart1683 He's dead. Hence rest in peace. He is resting (not moving) and he is at peace (his suffering has ended). His religion has nothing to do with it. Has anyone come back from the dead and told you anything different? I didn't think so.
Catholics are Christians
2:40 He certainly deliberately tried to end someone's life of the other side of that door.
It was delibrate homicide, but he was claiming that it was ‘self defence’ before anyone attacked him.
That was not self defence, which was the reason why he went straight to jail. 🤷
You obviously know nothing of the horrendous attacks and murders which take place on a daily basis in South Africa.
@@jillrobinson4297don't need to, he has a history of getting away with bad behavior and he should've served the full sentence.
He killed her out of rage , who knows why ?? Maybe she wanted
To leave him ? It wasn't self defense IMO . No way .
Again - YOU know nothing of the horrendous attacks and murders which take place on a daily basis in South Africa. Trust me - you would shoot first if in the same predicament. @@D-throne
@@miramaric4383 NOBODY claimed self defense. Oscar claimed from the very beginning that he thought it was an intruder. BIG difference. Also - minor detail which has escaped you - they had both been asleep - there was no rage.
His poor girlfriend can't go out and live her life. Her parents have been robbed of their grandchildren as well.
How many people on holiday with their wives and children shoot a gun through the bathroom door when they wake up and see a light on in their holiday apartment, toilet. Ridiculous story
Yes it was. And he should NEVER have been freed.
You are assuming she would have chosen to have had children.
BS@@ace6285
I never understood why would you shoot through an interior door not knowing where your girlfriend was?
He knew full well who was behind that door - and that’s precisely why he fired off 4 rounds.
Had it been an intruder locked in the bathroom, all he needed to do was call the police as that person was no of no threat at the stage to the lying Pistorius.
@@josimpson7999yes true.
@@josimpson7999not in South Africa. The police are hardly reliable and it’s a very violent country. You would expect an intruder there to be armed and be prepared to shoot.
However he should have verified where Reeva was before he shot the first round. IF he genuinely thought there was an intruder and he’d have called out her name she would have called back - unless she had reason to be scared and was hiding from him.
He knew fully well that Reeva was in there. What a WICKED WICKED SOUL Oscar is 😢
11 years! What price a life 😢
He's an intentional murderer. Plain and simple. He should be in prison for rest of his life. However, it is what it is and if he must live free I pray he lives good and doesn't hurt anybody else. How the system can not see what we all see i don't know. May reeva rest in peace x
I felt sick when I heard that news.
Sentence was too light. Its not right. He should remain in jail forever.
Why would a robber hide in a locked bathroom hiding. You’d be stealing the tv downstairs. Even so you wouldn’t shoot 4 times.
Fact that she locked herself in the bathroom says a lot about his demeanour
Why wouldn’t he have checked where Riva was before shooting through a door.He sounds an arrogant,entitled man.Riva was probably hiding and terrified from his controlling moods.These people can be charming one minute and mean and vicious,the next.He should not have been released.I hope women steer clear of him.
This lad is a monster
Bonus points for the ciggie behind his ear!
It's a pen or pencil
Haha he will probably spend 5 mins after this interview trying to find it 😂
The ciggie was funnier but still funny is him trying to find his pen 🤣🤣👌
Poor Pistorius confined to a heavily guarded mansion with beautiful grounds and a gorgeous swimming pool and tennis courts.
What a Parole 🎉🎉🎉🎉
HE IS LIVING THE GOOD LIFE WHILE REEVA ASHES IS IN THE OCEAN. NO JUSTICE DONE.
Why must an intruder lock himself/herself in bathroom? Doesnt make sense. This pistorious is a psychopath unable to deal with his challenges and has ptsd and killed a woman senselessly.
Human life is worth nothing anymore. Criminals get treated better and animals
How in Gods name did such a murderer get out of jail
He should NEVER have been released.
I predict he will not comply with his parole conditions and will revert to type and will be rearrested.
He’s a MONSTER.
well that news has me completely stumped!!!
Why were patio doors left open if he was worried about intruders.
exactly
That's the question the Judge never took in Consideration His Acting was better than his running
If your partner isn’t in bed at night they’re either in the toilet, getting a glass of water or outside having a cigarette. His story doesn’t make sense
exactly
Should have rotted in jail. He can now live in comfort, why he's victim's parents must grieve for the rest of their lives. You take a life, you lose your life.
No more peacocking for him. Guilty as sin itself.
Shame, shame, shame on a system that fails the victim...
Terrible. I don't think he has a leg to stand on.
Pistorious is a complete liar.
He is a spoiled Brat The Red mist came down and the rage took over He lost control just a selfish out of control brat
Off the topic:
Why mention that the judge was black? I'm just curious if there was a reason, bc he didn't say if the judge was a woman or a man...but that it was a black judge.
Threw me off too, but said nothing about the race and sex of oscar or reeva
He's simply anticipating someone suggesting that he received preferential treatment due to his race. It's more likely he was able to "sway" the justice system with his status and means to hire skilled/learned attorneys and PR personnel. He'd always maintained his original defense, and his legal counsel probably played on any lingering doubts regarding his guilt.
I thought it was odd too.
So that people don't think he got a light sentence because he had a white judge. It's very relevant in South Africa
imo - it was a case of “if i cant have you nobody else will”. He flipped -some men do.
The South African justice system doesn't have a leg to stand on.
A mistake to let him go.
He's gonna write a book, then give some speech about his experience then fade away
What about the movie deal ? Must have one
He can then be sued by reeva's estate
.
probably have his own tv show. lol
"The world at his feet" - unfortunate phrase.
🤣🤣 I spat my tea out when she said that… i was like, dont you mean stumps hahaa
Monster I hope he has lost the spring in his step he ain’t finished yet
Why didnt he alert reeva first before acting.
because he wanted her dead
exactly. guilty
He did! He told her to call the police. @@carrier411
You're believing his lies. Neighbors heard their raging fight and her screams. He chased her into the toilet and murdered her.
This man is too prejudiced in favour of Pistorius.
Did she really say world at his feet? You could tell she’s really proud of herself for that one.
Why has he been released? Sickening, he Murdered his Girlfriend. Sickening!
He will answer one day to God I don't believe Oscars version😱
I think her family should exact their own Justice
Hello, my comment is out of concept, but I just noticed, Mr. Carlin has forgotten a cigarette on his right ear, which I find a pleasant and authentic ritual of a writer 🤓
😂😂😂
Yes way he deliberately killed Reeva, huge picture of Reeva ???
Why was the fact the judge was black worth mentioning?
Hopefully Pistolrius doesn't shoot anyone else
The judge was totally unqualified for the role.
Or paid off !@@chesterdonnelly1212
@@chesterdonnelly1212 and suppose you ARE a qualified one?
@@lumumbamyeza5846 I am not a judge. But the case was quite a simple one. He murdered his girlfriend, then he lied.
He lived in a security complex and an intruder would not be likely.
Secondly, I don't know where this man lived in South Africa but the picture he paints is misleading. Crime is high and police are corrupt but there are plenty of safe places to live. I live in a walled non gated community in South Africa and do not even have an alarm system. We don't want people like him implying that South Africa is extremely dangerous. Glad he's gone.
I also lived in a gated community with high security in the Western Cape. No burglar bars, no safety gates, no alarms, sleeping with open gates...until a gang started targeting us, average 4 houses per night, even if you were inside you would wake up with them around your bed. After we all installed burglar bars, safety gates, alarms with armed response they still came in by shattering a non opening window with a spark plug. This only stopped when we started our own night patrol, and then 80% moved out of the complex. There is no such thing as a safe complex in South Africa
Clearly an entitled egotistic liar
I will appreciate it if you can mention any place that is safe in this South Africa.
Ha, tell that to one of the 28,000 murdered in 2023. Scariest place ever. Such a shame.
I went to SA 20 years ago, walked from my Hotel to the shopping Mall, 2 clicks (stretch the legs and get the vibes), everyone FREAKED out, I thought ....get a life.
He is a control freek and a psychopath with major anger issues and an uncontrollable temper. He should be in jail for life NO PAROLE. RIP Reeva😢
"Who's coming to dinner"?
"Oscar Pistorious"
"Oh, mother of Christ Woman. Pull up the drawbridge and say your prayers"
What he did was unforgivable but God knows best.
I agree 💯👍 only Oscar and God knows what happened on that night. Let us not through stones, as people are believing in hearsay ...
Does he
Then God should know better.
@@gadaffi1000 needless to be blasphemous.
DISGUSTING
"The world at his feet" lol 1:45
MURDERERS WALK AMONG US…
"... the world at his feet" may be the worst choice of words.
Did he really have the world at his feet? He doesn't have any feet! Nice to see somebody on screen with a cigarette behind their ear!
He should escape to Italy.
Well, okay, you had dinner and....
So if you say that South Africa is a very very violent place with lots of home invasions why is it not possible to believe his version of events?
Because neighbors heard their long raging fight and her screams, that's why.
He definately was an abusive boyfriend thats for sure, and i personally believe he shot through that door in anger knowing reeva was in there. No can know for definate because we werent there, but thats my belief. But south africa is constant paranoia and looking over your shoulder. I left for that reason. Fed up of bars and gate's and fear
Liar 🤥 liar 🤥 liar 🤥
I can't believe that was already 11 years ago oh my God
More than half his sentence
Hope no one gets in his way in the future!
He was jealous of his girlfriend and I think she was thinking of leaving him he would not let her go that why he shoot her. No respect for him he should have done the full prison sentence. He felt he was better than others just because he was a blade runner. God will judge him.
Disgraceful
@ John Carlin. @02.35 you state the skin colour/race of the judge. Relevance?
He is under probation and house arrest. Not entirely what I would call released.
He's alive, breathing, not dead in prime of life. And restrictions go away after 2 years.
@@judithgee7011 Well he also has a whole country who hates him.
Stop confusing Justice system with Justice or Truth or fairness. Its just a system often haphazardly administered. Sometimes innocent people go to jail, other times guilty people are set free, or never get charged in the first place. Its not uncommon for innocent people to plead guilty to avoid legal costs & stress especially if they cannot afford lawyers (so prosecutors intentionally draw out the proceedings). Oscar by staying home has to pay for his own lodging, the state saves about $200,000 (in the USA) per prisoner.
What is the reason…. Why he got out
Millady millady 😂
Oh right so justice was served here then😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
His girlfriend called him stumpy and he went crazy.
"The world at his feet" 😮
Pistorius, technically, isn't a nut.
It's a seed.
Because hes half the man he used to be?
“World at his feet?” Jesus Christ do your research woman!
It was deliberately said I believe
Did she really just say that!!?
@2:35 ...???
That first judge was a disgrace.
BS !
wrong
on many levels.!
🤔🙄
🕯🥺
#neverforgetmyname
#justice
#truthseekersunite
✌🏻🌏🇦🇺🤘🏻
What about nr 3 the rugby player. 😮 Please dont spoil our valentines again because of a woman without ethics. Reeva was no angle.
Angel
She's dead. By his hand. What's your point?
THAT DOES NOT MEAN SHE DESERVES TO BE KILLED.
What. a. shame
I do not believe he knew it was his girlfriend. I believe he was confused and fearful. He thought there was an intruder. I believe the "woman's" scream the neighbor heard was his unnaturally high voice.
Do you still believe in Father Christmas too? I didn't realize adults could be so gullible...
@@davidg3944 Two witnesses, who lived closer to him (next door) than the witness claiming they heard a woman's scream, both testified it was a man they heard scream. The witness who claimed they heard a woman scream, lived almost 600feet away. An acoustics expert at the trial testified that a woman's scream from inside the locked toilet, could not be heard 600 feet away. They also testified that a hysterical man's scream and a woman's scream, are indistinguishable. Know the facts of the case before you make such childish comments.
@@ScottyEire Ah, the Tooth Fairy appears as a character witness. Character witless is more like it...
You're welcome to believe in anything you'd like, the facts of the shooting make it absurdly reckless at best, planned criminality at worst (and in actuality). But stamp your feet if you feel like it, perhaps it'll stop you from kicking your dog.
Read the facts.
Hopefully he’ll reform and back on his feet again.
He doesn’t have feet.
@@MountainBikeBabe just googled it, you’re right I thought it was just legs he didn’t have.
The world at his feet... What feet? His parents had them chopped of above the knees when he was a baby. Think how he must have felt and the heroic amount of effort and courage his successes must have cost him. It's easy to patronize for all of us with two complete legs.
Unfortunate phrase
Who cares about that?!! He killed her in cold blood! Eleven years is a slap on the wrist! 😡
You don't assume that was literal, right? He was on top of his career.
The South African justice system doesn’t have a leg to stand on.
You have all facts wrong. He is psychopath.
He should get life.
Stop assuming / justice has taken its course whether you like it or not! This man has to live with his conscience whether clear or not.
No one is perfect and it’s not for you to cast judgement! Leave it to his creator! Find peace within yourselves!
You think her family thinks it fine and dandy that he's out when their beloved Reeva is dead and gone?
Hes served his sentance why is he not allowed to give interviews thats very suspicious
The most ridiculous story I ever herd, what would YOU do if you thought some one was in your bath room in the middle of the night ? I would go get my loved ones and exit as fast as possible, not go get my gun and fire into a closed door bathroom hoping to hit something, or maybe just leave and call the cops , ect...Common sense folks. I love moose, and I have a head of one mounted on my wall ?
That last sentence made sense to me because I'm living in Jokkmokk.
How many times have you had an intruder in your house? And do you live in South Africa?
I think the answer would be 'No' to both questions. I don't think people outside of SA understand the thousands of horrendous crimes which take place on a daily basis in South Africa.
It depends, right? If you live in South Africa or even the United States, your first reaction very well may be to go get your gun.
I don't know anything about this case, but from the facts laid out here in this short video, if indeed Pistorious thought there was an intruder (big "if" there), then yes, he may have reasonably gone to grab his gun first since, from what it sounds like, he is missing his lower limbs and may have doubted his own ability to fight off an intruder.
Why he didn't say fist, "Honey, is that you?" before firing, I do not know, but maybe she was out that night and he didn't expect her. Or maybe he assumed she was sleeping in a different room. I imagine he was asked that queetion by police and/or prosecutors.
But what I can tell you is that we have a lot of guns here in the US, ptobably about 1/3rd to half our population owns at least 1, and we have many very tragic incidents occur involving the shooting of the self or another, many including children getting a hold of improperly secured firearms.
If this guy was prosecuted in the US or SA, him grabbing his gun first may not have stood out as odd a behavior as it does seem to be in the UK.
No, and No , but he was already proven guilty in a Court of LAW! So what are you defending ? you want a retrial ?You have no argument what so ever.shooting threw a closed door is like shooting in a crowd and you should not be able to touch a gun with that stupidity period.@@priscillazietsman1300